# Accepted-Transition Claim Identity Reconciliation

Status: complete identity-resolution tranche; no support or release effect  
Snapshot: 2026-07-17  
Machine graph: `evidence_quality/claim_identity_graph.json`  
Governing roadmap: `docs/post_v2_3_maintenance_transfer_and_publication_roadmap.md`

## Result

All 115 review-accepted transitions now have exactly one primary canonical identity relation. There are 25 exact atom relations, 61 bounded subclaim relations, and 29 proxy relations. Zero accepted transitions remain unmapped.

This resolves ownership and traceability; it does not create evidence. An exact `atom` relation still uses the accepted-transition and registry-reconciliation process. A `subclaim_of` or `proxy_for` edge has no support-state effect on its parent. Proxy results cannot become target results without separate construct-validity evidence.

The canonical identity denominator is now 4,109: the current claim-atom registry, the historical 15-atom replaceable-substrates addendum, and the separately reviewed 30-atom R16-A addendum. The historical addenda remain separately versioned, and no support state moves.

## Adjudication method

The 90 non-direct claims were reviewed against their transition scope, named chapter surfaces, result artifacts, limitations, non-claims, and current manifest owner. No prefix matcher, first-chapter heuristic, or automatic parent promotion was used. Retired chapter-core claims were assigned to their current consolidated owner as bounded subclaims rather than aliases, because consolidation did not prove proposition identity.

Each graph row preserves population, environment, model, intervention, outcome, authority, time, artifact, maximum-inference, and parent-nonpromotion fields. The transition file digest makes silent outcome or scope rewriting detectable.

## High-risk decisions

- `kerc.broad_matched_total_system_efficiency` is a `proxy_for` the total-system KISS atom, not an exact architecture refutation. Its competence and N-level remain pending.
- `kerc.protected_exact_handle_preservation` is a bounded `subclaim_of` exact latent-state separation; it does not establish general semantic, security, or architecture behavior.
- QCSA exact-fixture claims remain subclaims or proxies under their current chapter owners; they do not promote QCSA, the integrated architecture, or any chapter core.
- The retired Agency, Command Contracts, Governance Rights, and Unified Tribunal core IDs are bounded subclaims under their consolidated owners, not identity aliases.
- The one existing `empirical-test-backed` local selector transition resolves as a proxy for Resource Economics; it is not the roadmap's still-missing competence-qualified natural, non-authored empirical result.

## Complete crosswalk

| Transition | Campaign claim | Relation | Canonical parent | Owner | Parent effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| `post_v2.governed_work_flagship.no_change` | `post_v2_governed_work_flagship.bounded_matched_local_result` | `proxy_for` | `intent-to-execution-contracts.core` | `intent-to-execution-contracts` | `none` |
| `post_v2.routing_deliberation.no_change` | `post_v2_routing_deliberation.bounded_matched_local_result` | `proxy_for` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores.core` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores` | `none` |
| `post_v2.update_causality.no_change` | `post_v2_update_causality.bounded_real_mutation_result` | `proxy_for` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning.core` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning` | `none` |
| `post_v2_1.ambiguous_routing.narrow` | `post_v2_1.ambiguous_routing.bounded_result` | `proxy_for` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores.core` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores` | `none` |
| `post_v2_1.full_state_rollback.narrow` | `post_v2_1.full_state_rollback.bounded_result` | `proxy_for` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback.core` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback` | `none` |
| `post_v2_1.full_state_update.no_change` | `post_v2_1.full_state_update.no_change_result` | `proxy_for` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning.core` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning` | `none` |
| `post_v2_1.governed_usefulness_rollback.narrow` | `post_v2_1.governed_usefulness_rollback.bounded_result` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `post_v2_1.real_model_deliberation.no_change` | `post_v2_1.real_model_deliberation.no_change_result` | `proxy_for` | `governed-deliberation-and-test-time-scaling.core` | `governed-deliberation-and-test-time-scaling` | `none` |
| `post_v2_1.unlearning_causality.narrow` | `post_v2_1.unlearning_causality.narrow_result` | `proxy_for` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning.core` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.governance_tax_natural_work.no_change` | `post_v2_3.governance_tax_natural_work.bounded_result` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.governance_tax_natural_work_renewal.no_change` | `resource_economics.governed_useful_throughput_under_natural_work` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.governed_usefulness_held_out_local.promote` | `governed-usefulness.held-out-local-policy-effect` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.kerc.broad_efficiency.refute` | `kerc.broad_matched_total_system_efficiency` | `proxy_for` | `replaceable-cognitive-substrates-beyond-transformer-monoculture.total-system-kiss` | `replaceable-cognitive-substrates-beyond-transformer-monoculture` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.kerc.protected_exact_handle.promote` | `kerc.protected_exact_handle_preservation` | `subclaim_of` | `replaceable-cognitive-substrates-beyond-transformer-monoculture.exact-latent-separation` | `replaceable-cognitive-substrates-beyond-transformer-monoculture` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.kerc.shared_glossary_break_even.promote` | `kerc.interaction_shared_glossary_break_even` | `proxy_for` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty.core` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.p5.authority_no_silent_expansion.promote` | `system-boundaries-and-authority.invariant.001` | `atom` | `system-boundaries-and-authority.invariant.001` | `system-boundaries-and-authority` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `post_v2_3.p5.circle_named_target_receipt.promote` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts.mechanism.003` | `atom` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts.mechanism.003` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `post_v2_3.p5.rollback_outcomes.narrow` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback.invariant.011` | `atom` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback.invariant.011` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_active_questions_exact_fixture_value.refute` | `qcsa.active_questions_exact_fixture_value` | `proxy_for` | `cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir.core` | `cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_certificate_authority_fields_exact_value.promote` | `qcsa.certificate_authority_fields_exact_value` | `subclaim_of` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.core` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_exact_synthetic_matched_advantage.refute` | `qcsa.exact_synthetic_matched_advantage` | `proxy_for` | `integrated-reference-architecture.core` | `integrated-reference-architecture` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_governance_prevention_resource_tradeoff.narrow` | `qcsa.governance_prevention_resource_tradeoff` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_identity_indirection_exact_migration_value.promote` | `qcsa.identity_indirection_exact_migration_value` | `subclaim_of` | `virtual-context-abi.core` | `virtual-context-abi` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_migration_compatibility_exact_value.promote` | `qcsa.migration_compatibility_exact_value` | `subclaim_of` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning.core` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_open_world_or_production_transfer.no_change` | `qcsa.open_world_or_production_transfer` | `proxy_for` | `integrated-reference-architecture.core` | `integrated-reference-architecture` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_plural_facets_exact_fixture_value.promote` | `qcsa.plural_facets_exact_fixture_value` | `subclaim_of` | `cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir.core` | `cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_reference_implementation_exact_contract_conformance.narrow` | `qcsa.reference_implementation_exact_contract_conformance` | `subclaim_of` | `integrated-reference-architecture.core` | `integrated-reference-architecture` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_semantic_round_trip_exact_preservation.narrow` | `qcsa.semantic_round_trip_exact_preservation` | `proxy_for` | `cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir.core` | `cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_task_calibration_exact_result.promote` | `qcsa.task_calibration_exact_result` | `subclaim_of` | `evidence-states-and-claim-discipline.core` | `evidence-states-and-claim-discipline` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.qcsa_vertical_reference_exact_reversible_trace.narrow` | `qcsa.vertical_reference_exact_reversible_trace` | `subclaim_of` | `integrated-reference-architecture.core` | `integrated-reference-architecture` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.residual_honesty_under_pressure.no_change` | `post_v2_3.residual_honesty_under_pressure.bounded_result` | `proxy_for` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty.core` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty` | `none` |
| `post-v2-3-m8-residual-verifier-terminal-instrument-failure` | `residual-verifier-capacity.heldout-pressure-effect` | `proxy_for` | `verification-bandwidth-and-context-adequacy.core` | `verification-bandwidth-and-context-adequacy` | `none` |
| `post-v2-3-m6-routing-deliberation-mixed-no-promotion` | `routing-deliberation.heldout-local-policy-effect` | `proxy_for` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores.core` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores` | `none` |
| `post_v2_3.situated_world_model.finite_pomdp.promote` | `situated-world-model.finite-pomdp-governed-acquisition-and-consolidation` | `subclaim_of` | `procedural-memory-and-cognitive-loop-closure.core` | `procedural-memory-and-cognitive-loop-closure` | `none` |
| `post-v2-3-m7-update-unlearning-claim-narrowed` | `update-unlearning.full-state-local-axis-separation` | `subclaim_of` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning.core` | `data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning` | `none` |
| `v1_0_measured.circle_external_rope_receipt.prototype_backed` | `circle-calculus.external_rope_receipt_replay` | `subclaim_of` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts.core` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_0_measured.costed_route_resource_slice.synthetic_test_backed` | `resource-economics.costed_route_budget_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_0_measured.phase5_harness_runner.synthetic_test_backed` | `living-book-methodology.phase5_harness_registry_runner` | `subclaim_of` | `living-book-methodology.core` | `living-book-methodology` | `none` |
| `v1_0_pilot.agency_corrigibility.no_change` | `agency-dignity-and-corrigibility.core` | `subclaim_of` | `constitutional-alignment-substrate.core` | `constitutional-alignment-substrate` | `none` |
| `v1_0_pilot.benchmark_ratchets.no_change` | `benchmark-ratchets-and-anti-goodhart-evidence.core` | `atom` | `benchmark-ratchets-and-anti-goodhart-evidence.core` | `benchmark-ratchets-and-anti-goodhart-evidence` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.capability_replacement.no_change` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback.core` | `atom` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback.core` | `capability-replacement-and-rollback` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.claim_ledgers.no_change` | `claim-ledgers-and-belief-revision.core` | `atom` | `claim-ledgers-and-belief-revision.core` | `claim-ledgers-and-belief-revision` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.command_contracts.no_change` | `command-contracts-and-semantic-interfaces.core` | `subclaim_of` | `intent-to-execution-contracts.core` | `intent-to-execution-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_0_pilot.constitutional_alignment.no_change` | `constitutional-alignment-substrate.core` | `atom` | `constitutional-alignment-substrate.core` | `constitutional-alignment-substrate` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.efficient_asi.no_change` | `the-efficient-asi-hypothesis.core` | `atom` | `the-efficient-asi-hypothesis.core` | `the-efficient-asi-hypothesis` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.evidence_states.no_change` | `evidence-states-and-claim-discipline.core` | `atom` | `evidence-states-and-claim-discipline.core` | `evidence-states-and-claim-discipline` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.fast_generation.no_change` | `fast-generation-architectures.core` | `atom` | `fast-generation-architectures.core` | `fast-generation-architectures` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.governance_rights.no_change` | `governance-rights-fork-exit-and-audit.core` | `subclaim_of` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict.core` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict` | `none` |
| `v1_0_pilot.intent_to_execution_contracts.no_change` | `intent-to-execution-contracts.core` | `atom` | `intent-to-execution-contracts.core` | `intent-to-execution-contracts` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.living_book_methodology.no_change` | `living-book-methodology.core` | `atom` | `living-book-methodology.core` | `living-book-methodology` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.moral_uncertainty.no_change` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict.core` | `atom` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict.core` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.planning_control.no_change` | `planning-as-a-control-layer.core` | `atom` | `planning-as-a-control-layer.core` | `planning-as-a-control-layer` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.proof_envelope.no_change` | `executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope.core` | `atom` | `executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope.core` | `executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.readiness_residual.no_change` | `readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine.core` | `atom` | `readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine.core` | `readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.recursive_self_improvement.no_change` | `recursive-self-improvement-boundaries.core` | `atom` | `recursive-self-improvement-boundaries.core` | `recursive-self-improvement-boundaries` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.research_agenda.no_change` | `open-research-agenda-and-bibliography-plan.core` | `atom` | `open-research-agenda-and-bibliography-plan.core` | `open-research-agenda-and-bibliography-plan` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.resource_economics.no_change` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `atom` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.runtime_adapters.no_change` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.core` | `atom` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.core` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.security_kernel.no_change` | `security-kernel-and-digital-scifs.core` | `atom` | `security-kernel-and-digital-scifs.core` | `security-kernel-and-digital-scifs` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.spinoza.no_change` | `spinoza-verification-and-proof-carrying-claims.core` | `atom` | `spinoza-verification-and-proof-carrying-claims.core` | `spinoza-verification-and-proof-carrying-claims` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.stable_capability_fields.no_change` | `stable-capability-fields.core` | `atom` | `stable-capability-fields.core` | `stable-capability-fields` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.system_boundaries.no_change` | `system-boundaries-and-authority.core` | `atom` | `system-boundaries-and-authority.core` | `system-boundaries-and-authority` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_0_pilot.uat.no_change` | `unified-adaptive-tribunal-and-adversarial-review.core` | `subclaim_of` | `scalable-oversight-and-adversarial-ai-control.core` | `scalable-oversight-and-adversarial-ai-control` | `none` |
| `v1_0_pilot.virtual_context_abi.no_change` | `virtual-context-abi.core` | `atom` | `virtual-context-abi.core` | `virtual-context-abi` | `exact_transition_record_subject_to_registry_reconciliation` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_epistemic_tcb_fixture.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.epistemic_tcb_fixture` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_github_pages_ci_attestation.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.github_pages_ci_attestation` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_live_attestation.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.live_artifact_attestation_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_public_site_attestation.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.public_site_record_reality_attestation` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_randomized_attestation.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.randomized_artifact_attestation_audit` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_receipt_faithfulness.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.receipt_faithfulness_adversarial_fixture` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_receipt_repository_audit_challenge.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.receipt_repository_audit_challenge` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.artifact_record_reality_sequence.no_change` | `artifact-graphs.record_reality_sequence_bridge` | `subclaim_of` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay.core` | `artifact-graphs-audit-logs-and-replay` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.authority_revocation_trace.no_change` | `system-boundaries.authority_revocation_trace` | `subclaim_of` | `system-boundaries-and-authority.core` | `system-boundaries-and-authority` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_contract_pack_archive.no_change` | `circle-calculus.contract_pack_archive` | `subclaim_of` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts.core` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_cyclic_mixer_receipt.no_change` | `circle-calculus.cyclic_mixer_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `coilra-multicoil-rope-and-cyclic-mixers.core` | `coilra-multicoil-rope-and-cyclic-mixers` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_kv_cache_receipt.no_change` | `circle-calculus.kv_cache_ring_buffer_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts.core` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_multicoil_phase_receipt.no_change` | `circle-calculus.multicoil_phase_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `coilra-multicoil-rope-and-cyclic-mixers.core` | `coilra-multicoil-rope-and-cyclic-mixers` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_public_consumer_gate.no_change` | `circle-calculus.public_consumer_gate` | `subclaim_of` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts.core` | `circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_recurrence_receipt.no_change` | `circle-calculus.recurrence_schedule_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts.core` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_seed_rule_receipt.no_change` | `compact-generative-systems.seed_rule_exact_regeneration_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty.core` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_sparse_attention_receipt.no_change` | `circle-calculus.sparse_attention_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts.core` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.circle_strided_fanout_receipt.no_change` | `circle-calculus.strided_fanout_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts.core` | `coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.compact_gvr_slice.synthetic_test_backed` | `compact-generative-systems.compact_gvr_receipt_slice` | `subclaim_of` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty.core` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.fast_generation_task_bundle.no_change` | `fast-generation-architectures.public_safe_task_bundle_accounting` | `subclaim_of` | `fast-generation-architectures.core` | `fast-generation-architectures` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.human_oversight_degradation.no_change` | `runtime-adapters.human_oversight_degradation` | `subclaim_of` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.core` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.partitioned_authority_fixture.no_change` | `personal-compute-hives.partitioned_authority_fixture` | `subclaim_of` | `personal-compute-hives-and-federated-edge-intelligence.core` | `personal-compute-hives-and-federated-edge-intelligence` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.planning_runtime_replan_delta.no_change` | `planning.runtime_replan_delta_audit` | `subclaim_of` | `planning-as-a-control-layer.core` | `planning-as-a-control-layer` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.planning_scheduler_state_probe.no_change` | `planning.scheduler_state_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `planning-as-a-control-layer.core` | `planning-as-a-control-layer` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.rankfold_artifact_import.no_change` | `rankfold-neuralfold.local_artifact_import_metadata` | `subclaim_of` | `rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression.core` | `rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.rankfold_public_safe_replay_probe.no_change` | `rankfold-neuralfold.public_safe_replay_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression.core` | `rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.readiness_lifecycle_probe.no_change` | `readiness-gates.readiness_lifecycle_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine.core` | `readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.residual_ledger_storage_replay.no_change` | `compact-generative-systems.residual_ledger_storage_replay` | `subclaim_of` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty.core` | `compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_ci_cost_profile.no_change` | `resource-economics.publication_pipeline_cost_profile` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_live_probe.no_change` | `resource-economics.local_replay_probe` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_load_stability_probe.no_change` | `resource-economics.synthetic_load_stability_route_selection` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_load_stability_selector.synthetic_test_backed` | `resource-economics.finite_burst_load_smoothing_selector` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_workflow_trace.no_change` | `resource-economics.workflow_trace_dispatch_accounting` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_workload_quality_probe.no_change` | `resource-economics.local_workload_quality_route_selection` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.resource_workload_quality_selector.empirical_test_backed` | `resource-economics.scoped_workflow_trace_route_selector` | `proxy_for` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.routing_decision_lease.no_change` | `routing-heads.synthetic_routing_decision_lease` | `subclaim_of` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores.core` | `routing-heads-and-specialist-cores` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.runtime_adapter_adversarial_boundary.no_change` | `runtime-adapters.adversarial_boundary_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.core` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.runtime_adapter_effect_probe.no_change` | `runtime-adapters.local_effect_replay_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.core` | `runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.security_scif_commit_probe.no_change` | `security-kernel.scif_sanitized_commit_replay` | `subclaim_of` | `security-kernel-and-digital-scifs.core` | `security-kernel-and-digital-scifs` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_accelerator_parity_manifest_import.prototype_backed` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.accelerator_parity_manifest_import` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_artifact_retention_replay_import.prototype_backed` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.artifact_retention_replay_gate_import` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_assistant_reference_trace_import.prototype_backed` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.assistant_reference_trace_import` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_book_crosswalk_import.no_change` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.book_to_theseus_crosswalk_pointer` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_governance_rights_receipt_suite_import.prototype_backed` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict.theseus_governance_rights_receipt_suite_import` | `subclaim_of` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict.core` | `moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict` | `none` |
| `theseus-module-definition-of-done-import-prototype-backed-2026-07-05` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.module_definition_of_done_gate_import` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `theseus-project-registry-import-prototype-backed-2026-07-05` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.project_registry_reality_import` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_public_task_bundle_import.no_change` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.public_task_bundle_import_summary` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_rlds_minari_trace_export_import.prototype_backed` | `resource-economics.theseus_rlds_minari_trace_export_import` | `subclaim_of` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_simulation_fidelity_receipt_suite_import.prototype_backed` | `resource-economics.simulation_fidelity_receipt_suite_import` | `subclaim_of` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets.core` | `resource-economics-and-token-budgets` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.theseus_work_board_import.no_change` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.work_board_currentness_import` | `subclaim_of` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.core` | `project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference` | `none` |
| `v1_x_measured.typed_job_durable_lifecycle_probe.no_change` | `labor-os.typed_job_durable_lifecycle_probe` | `subclaim_of` | `labor-os-and-typed-jobs.core` | `labor-os-and-typed-jobs` | `none` |

## Validation boundary

`python3 scripts/validate_claim_identity_graph.py` checks the exact accepted-transition denominator, transition digests, canonical parent existence and proposition, owner consistency, preserved artifacts and non-claims, zero indirect parent movement, deterministic regeneration, and twelve adversarial mutations.

This reconciliation does not rehabilitate historical negative results. P1 must still assign N0–N5 using the claim-bearing experiment competence standard before any negative or no-change result supports broader inference.