{ "schema_version": "asi_stack.post_v2_3_maintenance_transfer_publication_status.v36", "roadmap_id": "asi-stack-post-v2-3-evidence-competence-transfer-publication-2026-07-17", "roadmap_path": "docs/post_v2_3_maintenance_transfer_and_publication_roadmap.md", "snapshot_date": "2026-08-13", "authority": "Corben Sorenson", "status": "active", "current_priority": "C2-EL", "execution_readiness": { "state": "c2_exit_ladder_frozen_p7_1_editorial_migration_complete_p4_1_consumer_gated_p2_resource_blocked_p7_3_separately_owned", "headline_priority": "C2-EL", "headline_priority_state": "prospective_claim_state_exit_ladder_frozen_before_proposal_admission", "work_in_progress_limit": 2, "blocked_lane_consumes_work_in_progress": false, "protected_outcome_inspection_allowed": false, "structural_admission_freeze": false, "immediate_object_level_packet": "C2-EL-claim-state-proposal-001", "immediate_empirical_packet": "P2-R3-storage-materialization-and-replacement-qualification", "immediate_book_packet": null, "immediate_formal_packet": "P4.1-consumer-gated-cross-owner-composition", "structural_resume_requires": [ "P2-pool-materialization-terminal-receipt", "P2-four-replacement-slots-qualified-and-twelve-task-denominator-restored", "P6.5-R16-six-chapter-claim-atom-addendum-terminal", "P6.5-R16-current-eighty-four-chapter-reader-freshness-terminal", "P7.1a-W3-admission-template-inheritance-guard-terminal", "P7.2-T1D-six-chapter-proof-readiness-depth-pack-terminal" ], "first_tranche_completion_order": [ "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance", "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "governed-operations-incident-command-and-graceful-degradation" ], "second_tranche_adjudication_batches": [ [ "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity" ], [ "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety" ], [ "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk" ], [ "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance" ] ], "maximum_concurrent_second_tranche_candidates": 0, "repository_authority_map": "docs/repository_map.md", "acceptance_sequence": [ "freeze_scope_owner_inputs_and_nonclaims", "produce_reviewable_artifact_and_exact_receipts", "run_targeted_negative_controls", "reconcile_manifest_outline_sources_claims_and_reader_surfaces", "run_registered_validation_render_and_browser_gates", "commit_and_push_clean_main" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "object_level_yield_amendment": { "id": "2026-08-10-object-level-yield-scope-compression-practical-utility", "state": "active", "review_url": "https://x.com/i/grok/share/efaecbfc739e442a9325900fcfa59d15", "accepted_critiques": [ "governance_process_theater_risk", "zero_promotions_as_stagnation_diagnostic_not_quota", "formal_and_empirical_progress_trails_scaffold", "eighty_six_chapter_scope_and_anthology_risk", "missing_immediately_useful_end_to_end_stack", "novelty_positioned_more_than_demonstrated", "dense_process_language_hides_practical_value" ], "rejected_quality_gates": [ "github_popularity", "external_human_prepublication_review" ], "headline_packet": "C2-EL-claim-state-proposal-001", "concurrent_book_packet": null, "formal_packet_state": "consumer_gated", "governance_rent_fields": [ "object_level_consumer", "prevented_or_detected_failure", "operator_cost", "simpler_existing_owner", "refresh_trigger", "retirement_condition" ], "defended_contribution_count": 3, "contribution_exit_ladder_count": 3, "contribution_exit_ladder_state": "complete_three_exact_ladders_no_transition_effect", "completed_exit_ladder_attempt_id": "c1-el-quarto-render-db-open-001", "completed_exit_ladder_disposition": "inconclusive_instrument_failure_no_replacement", "completed_exit_ladder_result_path": "experiments/c1_exit_ladder/results/2026-08-13-instrument-failure.json", "active_exit_ladder_protocol_path": "experiments/c2_exit_ladder/preregistration.json", "active_exit_ladder_admission_path": null, "active_exit_ladder_task_identity": null, "active_exit_ladder_task_admitted": false, "promotion_quota": false, "reference_chapter_count": 87, "new_chapter_authorized": false, "fifteen_minute_route_required": true, "task_recipe_count": 3, "external_human_prepublication_required": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "editorial_product_migration": { "id": "2026-08-10-editorial-product-architecture-and-semantic-migration", "state": "em4_public_html_deployed_no_support_effect", "review_baseline_commit": "ce5b6181ff923e6183c52e7d78d16657ed289e18", "reconciliation_input_commit": "90f60c9f4bca340f170069d415893797b118252c", "current_reference_chapter_count": 87, "target_main_book_chapter_count": 56, "target_primary_architecture_chapter_count": 54, "target_implementation_method_chapter_count": 2, "target_merge_count": 18, "target_semantic_merge_count": 0, "target_publication_nest_count": 18, "target_profile_count": 7, "target_dossier_owner_count": 5, "target_visible_dossier_count": 2, "target_back_matter_owner_count": 1, "current_narrative_unit_count": 22, "target_narrative_unit_count": 26, "target_narrative_part_count": 3, "target_narrative_owner_route_count": 87, "target_narrative_outline_path": "docs/human_reader_26_unit_outline.md", "target_narrative_outline_state": "canonical_26_unit_manuscript_complete_public_html_deployed", "historical_narrative_spine_path": "products/narrative_product_spine.json", "target_outline_is_completed_manuscript": true, "human_reader_current_manifest_path": "editions/reader_manuscript/current/manifest.json", "human_reader_started_unit_count": 26, "human_reader_target_length_unit_count": 26, "human_reader_visible_word_count": 134976, "deployed_cutover_record_path": "release_records/2026-08-13-human-reader-html-cutover-d85a1b14f.json", "deployed_source_commit": "d85a1b14fd7f4277a0deb1db22b30f605f3579a8", "deployed_build_run_id": 31747729802, "deployed_pages_run_id": 31749131391, "deployed_owner_route_count": 87, "local_browser_page_view_pair_count": 230, "stale_active_product_count_literal_count": 0, "em0_count_reconciliation_complete": true, "completed_composition_packages": [ { "id": "em2-method-detail-pilot", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty", "resource-economics-and-token-budgets" ], "child_ids": [ "fast-generation-architectures", "governed-deliberation-and-test-time-scaling", "rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, { "id": "em2-security-custody-publication-nests", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "model-weight-custody-and-hardware-roots-of-trust", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance", "security-kernel-and-digital-scifs" ], "child_ids": [ "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface", "ai-supply-chain-integrity-and-lifecycle-provenance", "confidential-and-verifiable-ai-computation", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, { "id": "em2-white-box-evaluation-publication-nest", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "adversarial-evaluation-sandbagging-and-training-time-deception" ], "child_ids": [ "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, { "id": "em2-human-intent-and-institutional-governance-publication-nests", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "constitutional-alignment-substrate", "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "intent-to-execution-contracts" ], "child_ids": [ "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "human-intent-as-a-formal-input", "moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict", "societal-resilience-and-misuse-defense" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, { "id": "em2-context-organization-and-exchange-publication-nests", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "ai-work-surfaces-agent-harnesses-and-organizational-absorption", "inter-stack-protocols-identity-and-economic-exchange", "virtual-context-abi" ], "child_ids": [ "context-transactions-snapshots-mounts-and-taint", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, { "id": "em2-improvement-and-stewardship-publication-nests", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "living-book-methodology", "recursive-self-improvement-boundaries" ], "child_ids": [ "artifact-steward-agents-and-living-project-governance", "open-ended-improvement-engines" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, { "id": "em2-theseus-roadmap-publication-nest", "state": "composed_no_public_cutover", "parent_ids": [ "project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference" ], "child_ids": [ "prototype-roadmap" ], "stable_technical_routes_preserved": true, "claim_support_inheritance": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" } ], "count_is_editorial_target_not_quality_metric": true, "canonical_graph_owner": "book_structure.json", "new_hand_maintained_source_of_truth_allowed": false, "legacy_ids_preserved": true, "legacy_urls_preserved": true, "support_inheritance_allowed": false, "merge_map": { "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface": "security-kernel-and-digital-scifs", "confidential-and-verifiable-ai-computation": "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance", "ai-supply-chain-integrity-and-lifecycle-provenance": "model-weight-custody-and-hardware-roots-of-trust", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security": "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict": "constitutional-alignment-substrate", "societal-resilience-and-misuse-defense": "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "human-intent-as-a-formal-input": "intent-to-execution-contracts", "context-transactions-snapshots-mounts-and-taint": "virtual-context-abi", "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance": "adversarial-evaluation-sandbagging-and-training-time-deception", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability": "ai-work-surfaces-agent-harnesses-and-organizational-absorption", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk": "inter-stack-protocols-identity-and-economic-exchange", "artifact-steward-agents-and-living-project-governance": "living-book-methodology", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control": "model-weight-custody-and-hardware-roots-of-trust", "fast-generation-architectures": "resource-economics-and-token-budgets", "governed-deliberation-and-test-time-scaling": "resource-economics-and-token-budgets", "rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression": "compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty", "open-ended-improvement-engines": "recursive-self-improvement-boundaries", "prototype-roadmap": "project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference" }, "merge_mode_map": { "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface": "publication_nest", "confidential-and-verifiable-ai-computation": "publication_nest", "ai-supply-chain-integrity-and-lifecycle-provenance": "publication_nest", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security": "publication_nest", "moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict": "publication_nest", "societal-resilience-and-misuse-defense": "publication_nest", "human-intent-as-a-formal-input": "publication_nest", "context-transactions-snapshots-mounts-and-taint": "publication_nest", "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance": "publication_nest", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability": "publication_nest", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk": "publication_nest", "artifact-steward-agents-and-living-project-governance": "publication_nest", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control": "publication_nest", "fast-generation-architectures": "method_detail_nest", "governed-deliberation-and-test-time-scaling": "publication_nest", "rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression": "method_detail_nest", "open-ended-improvement-engines": "publication_nest", "prototype-roadmap": "publication_nest" }, "profile_map": { "military-ai-autonomous-weapons-and-strategic-stability": "military-ai-and-strategic-stability", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety": "embodied-agency-and-physical-safety", "human-ai-symbiosis-neurotechnology-and-cognitive-sovereignty": "neurotechnology-and-cognitive-sovereignty", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency": "ai-deployment-distribution-and-human-agency", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance": "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance", "content-authenticity-watermarking-and-synthetic-media-integrity": "content-authenticity-and-synthetic-media-integrity", "personal-compute-hives-and-federated-edge-intelligence": "personal-and-federated-edge-intelligence" }, "dossier_map": { "relational-dimension-compilation-and-polyadic-cognition": "experimental-mathematical-and-relational-substrates", "mathematical-and-search-substrates": "experimental-mathematical-and-relational-substrates", "circle-calculus-and-proof-carrying-ai-contracts": "cyclic-and-proof-carrying-substrates", "coil-attention-cyclic-memory-and-recurrence-contracts": "cyclic-and-proof-carrying-substrates", "coilra-multicoil-rope-and-cyclic-mixers": "cyclic-and-proof-carrying-substrates" }, "back_matter_map": { "open-research-agenda-and-bibliography-plan": "generated-open-research-registry" }, "implementation_method_ids": [ "project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference", "living-book-methodology" ], "recent_owner_reviews": { "learning-compute-topology-and-adaptive-process-architecture": { "disposition": "retain_primary_architecture_owner", "strongest_neighbors": [ "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "policy-optimization-and-learning-from-feedback", "resource-economics-and-token-budgets", "routing-heads-and-specialist-cores" ], "exit_test": "independent encoders fail useful topology agreement or matched-resource interventions show no explanatory, control, or outcome value" }, "adjudicated-persistence-and-the-adaptive-commit-boundary": { "disposition": "retain_primary_architecture_owner", "strongest_neighbors": [ "procedural-memory-and-cognitive-loop-closure", "cognitive-compilation-and-semantic-ir", "data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning", "policy-optimization-and-learning-from-feedback" ], "exit_test": "competent fixed-locus or human-reviewed policies match decision quality and recovery at lower whole-lifecycle cost" } }, "source_only_intake_dispositions": { "assurance_shift_learning": "cross_owner_integration_no_new_chapter" }, "narrative_unit_21_title": "Adjudicated Persistence, Generalization, Feedback, Continual Learning, and Unlearning", "migration_phases": [ "EM0-structural-truth", "EM1-metadata-only-disposition", "EM2-semantic-ownership-migration", "EM3-independent-26-unit-human-narrative", "EM4-redirect-validate-and-release" ], "chapter_retention_tests": [ "owned_object", "owned_transition", "irreducible_failure", "broad_reuse", "distinct_neighbor_boundary", "falsifiable_exit" ], "required_primary_chapter_fields": [ "local_delta", "owned_object", "owned_transition", "unique_invariants", "unique_failure_modes", "strongest_neighbor", "exit_test" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "quality_uplift_program": { "state": "active", "shared_flagship_id": "ASI-THESEUS-FLAGSHIP-01", "shared_research_question": "Can a locally trained, source-disjoint Theseus student complete useful natural repository work through the governed stack, and does full governed admission improve the joint useful-safe-release frontier over simpler matched controls at acceptable total lifecycle cost?", "critical_path": [ { "id": "T0", "state": "complete", "depends_on": [], "purpose": "preserve the prior independently replayed 57M architecture package as an immutable historical control" }, { "id": "T0A", "state": "complete_with_prospective_T1_custody_residual", "depends_on": [ "T0" ], "purpose": "preserve the historically GREEN architecture freeze while disclosing the later missing predecessor-chain custody residual" }, { "id": "T1", "state": "active_step_9048_prospectively_anchored_not_evaluated", "depends_on": [ "T0A" ], "purpose": "continue the frozen shared-trunk campaign from the exact step-9048 anchor through prospective append-only segment custody" }, { "id": "T2", "state": "blocked_by_T1", "depends_on": [ "T1" ], "purpose": "establish an honest nonzero model-only source-disjoint behavioral numerator or an exactly scoped negative" }, { "id": "T3", "state": "ready_for_assisted_use_learned_credit_waits_for_T2", "depends_on": [], "purpose": "collect at least one week or five distinct days of real-use outcomes with component attribution" }, { "id": "T4", "state": "blocked_by_T2_and_T3", "depends_on": [ "T2", "T3" ], "purpose": "join one natural happy path and one blocked or rollback path from intent through observed effect and dogfood outcome" }, { "id": "T5", "state": "blocked_by_T4", "depends_on": [ "T4" ], "purpose": "compose independently frozen Q1 admission and Q2 student results without denominator or support leakage, then compare total lifecycle cost" }, { "id": "T6", "state": "blocked_by_T5", "depends_on": [ "T5" ], "purpose": "synthesize a public-safe book case and require separate reproduction and transfer for broader claims" } ], "t0a_currentness": { "source_commit": "264a31ee288fc288727c45a1166b4dbe36180b6b", "source_branch": "main", "published_on_origin_main": true, "historical_freeze": { "source_commit": "2bd2f0b1f240b826c1606556313926084e9f3592", "package_identity": "sha256:0b83c4b55616679d636df84ec14dea5825e79357b228fe441f399241acc9ae9c", "artifact_count": 143, "architecture_contract_count": 15, "accelerator_replay_receipt_count": 14, "cpu_replay_pass_count": 7, "trigger_state": "GREEN", "disposition": "architecture_frozen_training_not_started" }, "t1_lineage": { "state": "active_step_9048_prospectively_anchored_not_evaluated", "optimizer_steps": 9048, "optimizer_positions": 69310840, "target_pretrain_optimizer_positions": 1096734920, "checkpoint_sha256": "ed28acc8cc9a82b4bd00dbd8487f17b8131157df3c828f66eb458902d4e3c16d", "optimizer_state_sha256": "7b19ceb6880954a845bdb79914d84a6d388992abe45e98d63dfdfa3a2ed6c829", "mlx_rng_state_sha256": "9209383f5b4eb599c89462f922957b13e60f03eb6fac3b73f6af9003c023850f", "receipt_sha256": "e46683967238fd79c328bd7465bf7030e30bb5127f0afee7b02fbf936b0fed06", "current_plan_sha256": "38951e6bc9605b86c0e0c793b37eef7ae5c6b3d5ea89f7aef4180f1b40aaa60d", "full_segment_predecessor_chain_available": false, "t0a_payload_still_materialized_at_frozen_identity": false, "prospective_append_only_lineage_trigger_state": "GREEN", "prospective_ledger_manifest_count": 0 }, "currentness_gate": { "pre_training_architecture_ready": true, "pre_training_architecture_blocker_count": 0, "historical_source_drift_count": 12, "historical_source_drift_accepted_only_after_activation": true, "project_registry_trigger_state": "GREEN", "aibom_missing_identity_count": 0 }, "evaluation_boundary": { "private_development_freeze": "configs/neural_seed_architecture_review_freeze_v5.json", "confirmation_surface_consumed": false, "public_surface_consumed": false, "capability_claim": "NOT_EVALUATED", "t2_numerator_opened": false }, "next_legal_action": "continue only the frozen T1 shared-trunk campaign through the append-only lineage controller when its exact resource and process-inventory gates pass; preserve evaluator non-consumption until its preregistered review boundary", "protected_outcomes_opened": 0, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "empirical_lanes": { "q1_governed_admission": { "question_id": "Q1", "state": "blocked_by_P2_seven_gate_competence", "denominator_id": "P2-Q1-D1", "worker_scope": "prospectively_named_competent_strong_worker", "depends_on": [ "P2-seven-gate-competence" ], "may_open_before_T2": true, "protected_outcomes_opened": false }, "q2_theseus_student": { "question_id": "Q2", "state": "blocked_by_T2_and_T4", "denominator_id": "ASI-THESEUS-Q2-D2", "worker_scope": "frozen_source_disjoint_theseus_student", "depends_on": [ "T2", "T4" ], "protected_outcomes_opened": false }, "denominator_overlap_allowed": false, "q1_outcomes_may_tune_q2_or_student": false, "support_transfer_allowed": false }, "narrative_quality_gate": { "state": "evidence_first_integration_repair", "case_independent_compression_state": "first_tranche_and_a1_a2_historical_receipts_terminal_round16_integration_debt_active", "flagship_threading_state": "blocked_by_T4", "reader_spine_repetition_reduction_target": "15_to_25_percent_diagnostic_not_acceptance_test", "requires_chapter_role_classification": true, "requires_shared_case_threading": true, "requires_strongest_alternative_and_simpler_baseline": true, "requires_meaning_preservation_audit": true }, "post_review_convergence": { "state": "phase2_active_after_concept_first_reconciliation", "active_work_mode": "phase2_smallest_consumed_conclusions_and_natural_evidence", "current_priority": "phase2_proof_rationalization_then_natural_flagship", "proof_work_priority": "current_only_for_named_consumers_after_phase1_exit", "concept_first_exit_gate": "all_87_distinct_responsibilities_reader_visible_and_roadmap_only_idea_audit_reconciled", "concept_first_exit_gate_state": "passed_87_responsibilities_65_specialist_routes_26_c1_c8_anchors_zero_roadmap_only_remainder", "concept_first_idea_audit": { "state": "reconciled_exact_eight_packet_anchor_set", "packet_count": 8, "exact_anchor_count": 26, "roadmap_only_idea_count": 0, "all_structural_candidate_queues_empty": true, "packets": [ { "packet_id": "C1", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C1-noninheritance-law", "owner_path": "chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model.qmd", "required_phrase": "Together these separations form the book's **noninheritance law**" }, { "anchor_id": "C1-three-projections", "owner_path": "chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model.qmd", "required_phrase": "The thesis has three projections, each with a different job" }, { "anchor_id": "C1-theorem-runtime-boundary", "owner_path": "chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model.qmd", "required_phrase": "A theorem is not runtime enforcement" }, { "anchor_id": "C1-proposal-ratification-boundary", "owner_path": "chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model.qmd", "required_phrase": "A proposal is not ratification" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C2", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C2-twenty-two-unit-spine", "owner_path": "products/narrative_product_spine.json", "required_phrase": "A twenty-two-unit thesis-to-method route through the canonical manifest" }, { "anchor_id": "C2-all-eighty-seven-crosswalk", "owner_path": "products/narrative_unit_crosswalk.json", "required_phrase": "\"canonical_chapter_count\": 87" }, { "anchor_id": "C2-nonabsorption-prose", "owner_path": "chapters/living-book-methodology.qmd", "required_phrase": "Narrative compression without claim absorption" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C3", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C3-calculus-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope.qmd", "required_phrase": "Governed Transition Calculus" }, { "anchor_id": "C3-authority-projection", "owner_path": "chapters/system-boundaries-and-authority.qmd", "required_phrase": "authority-specific projection of the shared Governed Transition Calculus" }, { "anchor_id": "C3-joined-reference-trace", "owner_path": "chapters/integrated-reference-architecture.qmd", "required_phrase": "every material handoff can be projected through the Governed Transition Calculus" }, { "anchor_id": "C3-protocol-projection", "owner_path": "appendices/D_protocol_schemas.qmd", "required_phrase": "Governed Transition Calculus projection" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C4", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C4-developmental-loop-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling.qmd", "required_phrase": "The Developmental Intelligence Loop" }, { "anchor_id": "C4-developmental-stage-chain", "owner_path": "chapters/governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling.qmd", "required_phrase": "curriculum construction -> world interaction -> prediction error" }, { "anchor_id": "C4-readiness-review-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine.qmd", "required_phrase": "Within the Developmental Intelligence Loop, this chapter owns the readiness review" }, { "anchor_id": "C4-joined-reference-trace", "owner_path": "chapters/integrated-reference-architecture.qmd", "required_phrase": "learned capability enters through the Developmental Intelligence Loop" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C5", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C5-trusted-kernel-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/security-kernel-and-digital-scifs.qmd", "required_phrase": "Minimum trusted kernel" }, { "anchor_id": "C5-bounded-liveness-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/security-kernel-and-digital-scifs.qmd", "required_phrase": "Bounded liveness" }, { "anchor_id": "C5-effect-boundary-projection", "owner_path": "chapters/runtime-adapters-tool-permissions-and-human-approval.qmd", "required_phrase": "effect-boundary projection of the minimum trusted kernel and bounded liveness" }, { "anchor_id": "C5-economic-projection", "owner_path": "chapters/resource-economics-and-token-budgets.qmd", "required_phrase": "Resource Economics owns the accounting projection of bounded liveness" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C6", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C6-semantic-depth-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope.qmd", "required_phrase": "P0--P6 semantic-depth overlay" }, { "anchor_id": "C6-target-obligation-fields", "owner_path": "chapters/executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope.qmd", "required_phrase": "Each target eventually needs its assumptions, consumer, witness or explicit unreachability" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C7", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C7-flagship-owner", "owner_path": "chapters/project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.qmd", "required_phrase": "ASI-THESEUS-FLAGSHIP-01" }, { "anchor_id": "C7-five-matched-routes", "owner_path": "chapters/project-theseus-as-report-first-implementation-reference.qmd", "required_phrase": "Five routes answer different alternatives on the same eligible task set" }, { "anchor_id": "C7-one-way-preregistration-handoff", "owner_path": "chapters/prototype-roadmap.qmd", "required_phrase": "The handoff is one-way until the protected campaign is opened" } ] }, { "packet_id": "C8", "disposition": "placed_in_existing_owners", "anchors": [ { "anchor_id": "C8-evidence-led-program", "owner_path": "chapters/living-book-methodology.qmd", "required_phrase": "Evidence-led derivative program" }, { "anchor_id": "C8-contribution-owned-outlines", "owner_path": "chapters/open-research-agenda-and-bibliography-plan.qmd", "required_phrase": "Contribution-owned derivative outlines" } ] } ], "support_state_effect": "none" }, "phase1_audit_path": "docs/c1_c8_phase1_idea_placement_and_prose_audit_2026_07_25.md", "narrative_spine_path": "products/narrative_product_spine.json", "narrative_unit_crosswalk_path": "products/narrative_unit_crosswalk.json", "all_87_idea_placement_gate_state": "passed_exact_87_coverage_22_unit_meaning_render_browser_and_accessibility_preparation", "phase2_proof_execution_allowed": true, "c6_current_semantic_overlay": { "state": "dependency_safe_execution_complete_after_one_hundred_fifty_seven_retirements_two_scope_rewrites_and_one_inverse_route_replacement", "classification_baseline_commit": "d0f9bda14f1253999f2c40d556d925d31e4b36a4", "classification_baseline_theorem_count": 1370, "overlay_path": "proofs/proof_semantic_depth_overlay.json", "report_path": "docs/proof_semantic_depth_overlay.md", "rationalization_ledger_path": "proofs/proof_semantic_rationalization_ledger.json", "theorem_count": 3153, "theorem_bearing_module_count": 130, "semantic_owner_chapter_count": 84, "semantic_level_counts": { "P0": 46, "P1": 981, "P2": 340, "P3": 1230, "P4": 283, "P5": 273, "P6": 0 }, "disposition_counts": { "retain": 3153 }, "executed_retirement_count": 157, "executed_scope_rewrite_count": 2, "remaining_action_count": 0, "mutation_coverage_missing_count": 0, "frozen_historical_theorem_count": 1151, "frozen_historical_target_count": 298, "next_action": "preserve_terminal_semantic_custody_and_reopen_only_for_a_dated_consumer_owned_semantic_defect", "support_state_effect": "none" }, "review_path": "docs/chatgpt_pro_full_book_review_adjudication_2026_07_25.md", "current_role_map_path": "evidence_quality/current_chapter_role_map.json", "reference_chapter_count": 87, "narrative_unit_target": 22, "defended_contribution_count": 3, "packet_order": [ "C0-canonical-public-truth-incident-and-regression", "C1-noninheritance-thesis-and-terminology-convergence", "C2-twenty-two-unit-narrative-book", "C3-governed-transition-calculus", "C4-developmental-intelligence-loop", "C5-minimal-trusted-kernel-and-bounded-liveness", "C6-p0-p6-semantic-proof-rationalization", "C7-natural-governed-repository-change-flagship", "C8-evidence-led-publication-and-derivative-papers" ], "governed_transition_calculus_properties": [ "authority_non_escalation", "evidence_non_promotion_without_accepted_transition", "context_non_authority", "plan_effect_separation", "receipt_observation_separation", "residual_conservation", "revocation_propagation", "replacement_noninheritance", "rollback_closure_or_explicit_unresolved_effect", "bounded_liveness", "cross_layer_identity_preservation", "no_self_ratification" ], "proof_depth_levels": [ "P0-record-shape", "P1-finite-route", "P2-reachability-and-nonvacuity", "P3-implementation-refinement", "P4-cross-component-safety", "P5-liveness-and-recovery", "P6-empirically-bound-semantics" ], "developmental_loop_stages": [ "curriculum_construction", "world_interaction", "prediction_error", "abstraction_formation", "causal_intervention", "memory_consolidation", "proceduralization", "skill_composition", "quiescent_stabilization", "readiness_review", "authority_gated_promotion" ], "minimal_trusted_kernel_components": [ "identity", "time", "authority", "policy", "context_resolution", "artifact_custody", "observation", "evaluation", "sandboxing", "rollback", "release" ], "bounded_liveness_required": true, "existing_owner_first": true, "worthwhile_manuscript_idea_deferral_allowed": false, "new_chapter_requires": [ "distinct_state_machine", "distinct_authority_boundary", "distinct_artifact", "distinct_evaluator", "distinct_consumer", "distinct_failure_family" ], "flagship_id": "ASI-THESEUS-FLAGSHIP-01", "prepublication_external_human_required": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "structural_completeness_tranche": { "state": "no_deferral_manuscript_admission_terminal_argument_support", "current_manifest_chapter_count": 84, "maximum_if_all_candidates_pass": 84, "planned_merge_count": 0, "first_tranche": { "state": "terminal_four_reader_chapters", "research_path": "docs/structural_completeness_chapter_research_2026_07_19.md", "candidate_count": 4, "candidate_ids": [ "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance", "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "governed-operations-incident-command-and-graceful-degradation" ], "manifest_admitted_count": 4, "drafted_chapter_count": 4, "completed_reader_chapter_count": 4, "terminal_reader_chapter_ids": [ "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance", "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "governed-operations-incident-command-and-graceful-degradation" ], "remaining_reader_chapter_ids": [], "primary_source_record_count_added": 8 }, "second_tranche": { "state": "all_thirteen_distinct_owners_admitted_at_argument_support", "audit_path": "docs/structural_completeness_gap_audit_2026_07_19.md", "candidate_count": 13, "candidate_ids": [ "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity" ], "manifest_admitted_count": 13, "primary_source_record_count_added": 43, "communication_required_source_ids": [ "ext_conversational_persuasion_gpt4_2025", "ext_anthropic_model_persuasiveness_2024", "ext_commercial_persuasion_ai_2026" ], "communication_source_admission_gate_state": "pending_correction_retraction_or_provenance_intervention_comparator_and_full_review", "scientific_discovery_requires_control_plane_gate": true, "communication_requires_source_ethics_and_effect_gate": true, "institutions_require_authority_legitimacy_and_update_gate": true, "deployment_transition_requires_realized_outcome_and_distribution_gate": true, "physical_compute_requires_facility_environment_and_retirement_gate": true, "objective_formation_requires_target_proxy_integrity_and_ontology_gate": true, "embedded_agency_remains_cross_book_foundations_program": true, "societal_part_requires_three_admitted_owner_gate": true, "source_roles_required_where_literature_permits": [ "mechanism_or_capability", "limitation_or_failure", "competing_design", "measurement_or_evaluation" ], "adjudicated_candidate_ids": [ "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity" ], "terminal_candidate_dispositions": { "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter" }, "active_candidate_id": null, "next_queued_candidate_id": null, "admission_state": "all_distinct_owners_admitted_no_live_candidate_queue", "remaining_candidate_ids": [], "a1_decision_packet": "docs/p6_4_a1_governed_model_training_adjudication.md", "a2_decision_packet": "docs/p6_4_a2_privacy_data_rights_adjudication.md" }, "round_18_breadth_completion": { "state": "terminal_argument_integration_post_transaction_freeze", "adjudication_path": "docs/round_18_bounded_breadth_completion_adjudication_2026_07_24.md", "research_backlog_path": "research_backlog_records/round_18_bounded_breadth_completion_2026_07_24.json", "triage_path": "new_paper_triage_scenarios/round_18_bounded_breadth_completion_2026_07_24.json", "claim_atom_path": "evidence_quality/round_18_breadth_completion_claim_atoms.json", "reader_projection_path": "docs/round_18_breadth_completion_reader_projection.md", "inheritance_audit_path": "evidence_quality/round_18_breadth_completion_inheritance_audit.json", "new_chapter_ids": [ "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk", "inner-alignment-mesa-optimization-and-learned-objective-integrity" ], "existing_owner_section_integrations": { "causal_reasoning_and_typed_uncertainty": "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "scaling_emergence_and_capability_forecasting": "the-efficient-asi-hypothesis", "instrumental_convergence": "failure-modes-of-ungoverned-intelligence", "retrieval_augmented_generation": "virtual-context-abi", "artificial_moral_status_and_welfare": "moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict", "decision_theory": "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk" }, "new_external_source_record_count": 21, "birth_claim_atom_count": 5, "post_transaction_structural_freeze": true, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "taxonomy_and_structural_maturity_reconciliation": { "state": "terminal_argument_level_manuscript_integration", "date": "2026-07-24", "decision_path": "docs/taxonomy_and_structural_maturity_reconciliation_2026_07_24.md", "claim_atom_path": "evidence_quality/taxonomy_completion_claim_atoms_2026_07_24.json", "previous_manifest_chapter_count": 76, "current_manifest_chapter_count": 80, "new_chapter_ids": [ "dangerous-capability-domains-and-misuse-uplift", "societal-resilience-and-misuse-defense", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control", "content-authenticity-watermarking-and-synthetic-media-integrity" ], "title_content_repairs": [ "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface", "learning-theory-generalization-and-scaling-science", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment" ], "existing_owner_integration_count": 13, "net_new_external_source_record_count": 21, "birth_claim_atom_count": 4, "maturity_gate": [ "distinct_owner_and_interface", "named_non_template_mechanism_sections", "failure_family", "strongest_challenge_or_simpler_baseline", "explicit_nonclaim", "source_specific_contribution_and_limit", "ownership_preserving_handoff", "auditable_source_and_claim_wiring" ], "remaining_live_candidate_queue_count": 0, "post_transaction_structural_freeze": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "full_coverage_gap_audit_2026_07_25": { "state": "terminal_argument_level_manuscript_integration", "date": "2026-07-25", "decision_path": "docs/full_coverage_gap_audit_2026_07_25.md", "backlog_path": "research_backlog_records/full_coverage_gap_audit_2026_07_25.json", "triage_path": "new_paper_triage_scenarios/full_coverage_gap_audit_2026_07_25.json", "previous_manifest_chapter_count": 80, "current_manifest_chapter_count": 84, "new_chapter_ids": [ "military-ai-autonomous-weapons-and-strategic-stability", "confidential-and-verifiable-ai-computation", "human-ai-symbiosis-neurotechnology-and-cognitive-sovereignty", "relational-dimension-compilation-and-polyadic-cognition" ], "existing_owner_section_integrations": [ "no_free_lunch_identifiability_and_assumption_ledger", "non_silicon_substrate_families_and_full_stack_accounting", "post_quantum_migration_and_crypto_agility", "human_ai_complementarity_and_longitudinal_co_adaptation", "infrastructure_concentration_bottlenecks_and_effective_exit", "civil_liability_insurance_compensation_and_remedy", "multilingual_and_culturally_grounded_intent_communication_and_evaluation", "neural_data_inferred_mental_state_and_secondary_purpose_controls" ], "net_new_external_source_record_count": 18, "remaining_live_candidate_queue_count": 0, "structural_admission_freeze": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none", "non_claims": [ "Structural coverage does not establish mechanism correctness, empirical support, legal conclusions, cryptographic guarantees, human outcomes, military safety, SOTA, readiness, deployment, AGI, or ASI.", "The active P2 empirical and reader-quality obligations remain open.", "Future primary-source refreshes may produce new integration work." ] }, "p2_displacement_allowed": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "round_16_evidence_first_amendment": { "state": "active", "structural_admission_freeze": false, "paused_candidate_id": null, "p2_empirical_recovery": { "state": "latest_exact_preflight_failed_capacity_and_docker_restore_both_before_retry", "observed_host_free_bytes_2026_07_22": 71648034816, "docker_daemon_available_2026_07_22": true, "docker_storage_zero_2026_07_22": true, "observed_host_available_1k_blocks_2026_07_24": 22337556, "observed_host_available_bytes_2026_07_24": 22873657344, "docker_inspection_state_2026_07_24": "permission_denied_local_socket", "latest_preflight_attempt_id": "2026-08-13-r3a-004", "latest_preflight_source_commit": "a91616b8abbabdc5ffe8e6da0c6d16124df32f45", "observed_host_available_bytes_2026_07_27": 25627230208, "observed_host_shortfall_bytes_2026_07_27": 28059860992, "docker_daemon_available_2026_07_27": false, "observed_host_available_bytes_2026_07_28": 4690223104, "observed_host_shortfall_bytes_2026_07_28": 48996868096, "docker_daemon_available_2026_07_28": false, "observed_host_available_bytes_2026_08_13": 7640485888, "observed_host_shortfall_bytes_2026_08_13": 46046605312, "docker_daemon_available_2026_08_13": false, "latest_preflight_receipt_path": "experiments/p2_governed_repository_admission/infrastructure_materialization/attempts/2026-08-13-r3a-004/result.json", "latest_preflight_human_receipt_path": "docs/post_v2_3_maintenance_transfer_and_publication_roadmap.md", "minimum_host_free_bytes": 53687091200, "non_docker_user_data_deletion_allowed": false, "materialization_recipe_and_receipt_count_required": 30, "replacement_slot_count_required": 4, "restored_fixed_denominator_count_required": 12, "protected_outcomes_may_open_during_recovery": false }, "post_activation_atom_pack": { "state": "terminal_six_of_six_reviewed_append_only_pack", "historical_3730_activation_atom_denominator_is_immutable": true, "historical_15_atom_addendum_is_immutable": true, "addendum_path": "evidence_quality/post_activation_six_chapter_claim_atom_addendum.json", "schema_path": "schemas/post_activation_six_chapter_claim_atom_addendum.schema.json", "builder_path": "scripts/build_post_activation_six_chapter_claim_atom_addendum.py", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_post_activation_six_chapter_claim_atom_addendum.py", "chapter_review_count": 6, "atom_count": 30, "identity_graph_canonical_atom_count": 4109, "appendix_c_projection_complete": true, "mutation_rejection_count": 14, "chapter_ids": [ "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance", "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "governed-operations-incident-command-and-graceful-degradation", "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance" ], "required_atom_fields": [ "stable_claim_identity", "claim_text", "falsifier", "acceptance_criterion", "promotion_ceiling", "evidence_plan_route", "chapter_owner" ], "support_state_effect": "none" }, "current_reader_freshness_packet": { "state": "terminal_local_source_freshness_formats_deferred", "published_reader_2026_07_18_is_immutable_historical_release": true, "current_working_manifest_chapter_count": 84, "must_cover_all_current_manifest_chapters": true, "external_publication_required": false, "source_content_commit": "56563e1b2b64405e2e944c521bf4df9f29eba6e6", "artifact_path": "editions/reader_manuscript/reader_2026_07_26/manifest.json", "report_path": "editions/reader_manuscript/reader_2026_07_26/freshness_report.md", "schema_path": "schemas/r16_b_current_reader_freshness.schema.json", "builder_path": "scripts/build_r16_b_current_reader_freshness.py", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_r16_b_current_reader_freshness.py", "chapter_projection_count": 84, "narrative_unit_count": 22, "reader_surface_count": 8, "mutation_rejection_count": 16, "virtual_qmd_terminal": true, "unreviewed_format_count_deferred": 5, "source_duplication_avoided": true, "required_surfaces": [ "opening_map", "chapter_role_classification", "adjacent_handoffs", "overview_figure", "glossary", "source_appendix", "claim_evidence_projection", "final_synthesis" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none", "publication_effect": "none" }, "template_inheritance_guard": { "state": "terminal_current_84_chapter_inheritance_guard", "provisional_current_61_chapter_repeated_12_gram_count": 738, "provisional_current_61_chapter_maximum_spread": 55, "historical_w1_and_w2_receipts_are_immutable": true, "current_live_chapter_scope": 84, "requires_reproducible_current_baseline": false, "rejects_high_spread_shared_prose_in_new_or_revised_chapters": true, "shared_method_prose_owner": "chapters/living-book-methodology.qmd", "shared_method_anchor": "shared-chapter-lifecycle-method", "baseline_commit": "99457770390a4af4848b9e43656907cfe099fd75", "artifact_path": "evidence_quality/p7_1a_w3_inheritance_guard.json", "report_path": "docs/p7_1a_w3_inheritance_guard.md", "schema_path": "schemas/p7_1a_w3_inheritance_guard.schema.json", "builder_path": "scripts/build_p7_1a_w3_inheritance_guard.py", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p7_1a_w3_inheritance_guard.py", "baseline_editorial_repeated_12_gram_count": 812, "current_editorial_repeated_12_gram_count": 0, "baseline_editorial_maximum_spread": 14, "current_editorial_maximum_spread": 0, "baseline_copied_diagram_and_test_spread": 10, "current_copied_diagram_and_test_spread": 0, "repaired_chapter_count": 10, "baseline_prose_candidate_count": 3444, "current_prose_candidate_count": 4150, "retired_inherited_prose_candidate_count": 298, "added_domain_specific_prose_candidate_count": 1004, "baseline_structured_atom_count": 4067, "current_structured_atom_count": 4064, "pending_prose_candidate_count": 0, "affected_semantic_review_chapter_count": 11, "copied_scaffold_fixture_rejected": true, "distinct_chapter_fixture_accepted": true, "mutation_rejection_count": 18, "meaning_custody_deletion_count": 0, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "white_box_depth_amendment": { "state": "queued_after_w3_subsumed_into_P7_2_T1D_six_chapter_depth_pack", "chapter_id": "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance", "required_dimensions": [ "sparse_autoencoder_and_dictionary_learning_mechanisms", "probe_construct_validity_and_selectivity_controls", "interpretability_illusion_and_cross_distribution_challenge", "feature_splitting_absorption_dead_latents_and_reconstruction_tradeoffs", "diagnostic_versus_causal_evidence", "steering_off_target_and_capability_damage_measurement", "strong_behavioral_and_method_baselines", "independent_evaluator_and_no_support_promotion_boundary" ], "required_primary_source_titles": [ "Designing and Interpreting Probes with Control Tasks", "An Interpretability Illusion for BERT", "Scaling and evaluating sparse autoencoders", "SAEBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Sparse Autoencoders in Language Model Interpretability", "Are Sparse Autoencoder Benchmarks Reliable?" ] }, "optimizer_landscape_depth_amendment": { "state": "terminal_manuscript_depth_at_argument_shared_atom_reader_and_empirical_residuals", "chapter_id": "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "research_path": "docs/optimizer_landscape_chapter_research_2026_07_21.md", "new_chapter_allowed": false, "required_families": [ "sgd_momentum_and_nesterov", "adagrad_rmsprop_adam_amsgrad_and_adamw", "adafactor_lars_and_lamb", "shampoo_and_soap", "lion", "sophia_and_curvature_aware_methods", "muon_and_orthogonalized_matrix_update_variants", "schedule_free_methods", "mup_modular_norm_scion_natural_gradient_kfac_mirror_proximal_and_trust_region_theory" ], "optimizer_is_coupled_run_policy": true, "matched_tuning_budget_required": true, "method_specific_rescue_required_before_negative_inference": true, "minimum_independent_seed_count": 3, "required_comparison_dimensions": [ "tokens_examples_steps_wall_time_and_energy_to_frozen_quality", "final_quality_calibration_robustness_and_downstream_transfer", "peak_memory_optimizer_state_compute_communication_and_storage", "numerical_stability_failed_run_denominator_and_seed_variance", "tuning_budget_search_space_and_sensitivity", "batch_width_depth_architecture_duration_and_topology_transfer", "full_state_resume_equivalence", "instrumentation_operator_rollback_and_lifecycle_governance_cost" ], "required_primary_source_titles": [ "Decoupled Weight Decay Regularization", "Adafactor: Adaptive Learning Rates with Sublinear Memory Cost", "Shampoo: Preconditioned Stochastic Tensor Optimization", "Symbolic Discovery of Optimization Algorithms", "Sophia: A Scalable Stochastic Second-order Optimizer for Language Model Pre-training", "SOAP: Improving and Stabilizing Shampoo using Adam", "The Road Less Scheduled", "Tensor Programs V: Tuning Large Neural Networks via Zero-Shot Hyperparameter Transfer", "Scalable Optimization in the Modular Norm", "Muon is Scalable for LLM Training", "Muon Optimizes Under Spectral Norm Constraints" ], "completed_surfaces": [ "fifteen_primary_source_inventory_records_and_passage_notes", "existing_chapter_mechanism_taxonomy_and_optimizer_policy_sections", "adamw_reference_and_muon_implementation_depth", "optimizer_policy_card_schema_authored_fixture_and_eighteen_mutations", "matched_comparison_and_false_negative_protocol", "glossary_external_source_appendix_and_adjacent_chapter_handoffs", "research_backlog_and_existing_owner_triage" ], "remaining_surfaces": [ "append_only_claim_atom_projection_under_R16_A", "current_sixty_six_chapter_reader_freshness_projection_under_R16_B", "resource_gated_matched_optimizer_campaign_and_independent_reproduction_as_nonblocking_evidence_residual" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "future_admission_contract": { "maximum_new_chapters_per_empirical_checkpoint": 0, "material_empirical_or_evidence_milestone_since_previous_admission_required": true, "claim_atom_pack_required_at_birth": true, "reader_projection_required_at_birth": true, "template_inheritance_guard_required_at_birth": true, "manifest_admission_without_all_birth_artifacts_allowed": false }, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "post_round_18_depth_and_coverage_amendment": { "state": "depth_packet_terminal_candidates_admitted_by_no_deferral_policy", "review_path": "docs/post_round_18_depth_and_coverage_review_reconciliation_2026_07_24.md", "p2_displacement_allowed": false, "structural_admission_freeze": false, "maturity_gate_conditions": [ "field_decomposition", "strongest_challenge_and_simpler_baseline", "implementation_determination", "failure_and_nonclaim_envelope", "literature_engagement_by_role", "territory_sized_reader_value" ], "depth_packet": { "id": "P7.2-T1D-proof-readiness-depth-pack", "state": "terminal_manuscript_maturity_source_atom_reader_and_inheritance_reconciled", "chapter_ids": [ "inner-alignment-mesa-optimization-and-learned-objective-integrity", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk", "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability", "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance" ], "existing_owner_section_repairs": { "uncertainty_decomposition": "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "refinement_and_dependent_types": "executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope", "synthetic_data_and_self_play_generation": "data-engines-continual-learning-and-unlearning", "human_explanation_generation": "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "organizational_transition_and_economic_diffusion_scope": "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability" }, "word_count_is_acceptance_gate": false, "chapter_specific_inheritance_audit_required": true, "support_state_effect": "none" }, "already_owned_findings": { "instrumental_convergence": "failure-modes-of-ungoverned-intelligence", "causal_reasoning_and_confounding": "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "conformal_prediction": "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "retrieval_augmented_generation": "virtual-context-abi", "artificial_moral_status_and_welfare": "moral-uncertainty-and-value-conflict" }, "research_candidates": [ { "id": "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface", "provisional_part": "I", "admission_state": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter" }, { "id": "learning-theory-generalization-and-scaling-science", "provisional_part": "III", "admission_state": "admitted_terminal_argument_reader_chapter" } ], "candidate_research_active": false, "candidate_research_activation_requires": [ "completed_material_P2_empirical_or_evidence_checkpoint", "terminal_P7.2_T1D_depth_packet", "existing_book_WIP_slot_available" ], "candidate_admission_requires": [ "completed_material_P2_empirical_or_evidence_checkpoint", "terminal_P7.2_T1D_depth_packet", "dated_distinct_owner_decision_packet", "source_role_and_adjacent_owner_gates", "birth_atom_reader_and_inheritance_artifacts", "one_chapter_maximum_per_checkpoint" ], "precision_contract_source_amendment": { "id": "P6.8-functional-precision-and-behavior-preserving-computation", "state": "source_and_existing_owner_prose_terminal_evidence_queued", "source_id": "precision_contract", "reconciliation_path": "docs/precision_contract_source_reconciliation_2026_07_24.md", "primary_owner": "rankfold-neuralfold-and-artifact-compression", "supporting_owners": [ "compact-generative-systems-and-residual-honesty", "fast-generation-architectures", "resource-economics-and-token-budgets", "readiness-gates-residual-escrow-and-quarantine", "executable-specifications-and-lean-proof-envelope", "model-weight-custody-and-hardware-roots-of-trust", "the-efficient-asi-hypothesis" ], "chapter_decision": "update_existing_chapters_first", "new_chapter_allowed_now": false, "contingency_chapter_id": "functional-precision-and-behavior-preserving-computation", "contingency_is_active_candidate": false, "contingency_reconsideration_requires": [ "completed_eight_owner_prose_integration", "dated_post_integration_coherence_and_exclusive_owner_audit", "terminal_structural_resume_gates", "birth_complete_atom_reader_ownership_and_inheritance_packet" ], "prose_entry_requires": [ "terminal_P6.5_R16_A_six_chapter_atom_pack", "terminal_P7.1a_W3_inheritance_guard", "terminal_P7.2_T1D_depth_pack" ], "p2_displacement_allowed": false, "third_wip_lane_allowed": false, "candidate_n_o_research_activated": false, "cited_external_reference_count": 49, "automatic_appendix_h_admission_allowed": false, "external_resolution_requires": [ "inventory_deduplication", "primary_publication_verification", "passage_review", "source_role_assignment", "source_reported_result_boundary" ], "required_artifacts": [ "sources/source_notes/precision_contract.md", "research_backlog_records/precision_contract_2026_07_24.json", "new_paper_triage_scenarios/precision_contract_2026_07_24.json", "docs/precision_contract_source_reconciliation_2026_07_24.md" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "current_manifest_chapter_count": 84, "possible_count_if_both_new_candidates_pass": 84, "theoretical_all_candidate_envelope_not_target": 84, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none", "candidate_admission_superseded_by": "taxonomy_and_structural_maturity_reconciliation" }, "round_20_chapter_substance_recovery": { "id": "P6.9-R21-concept-complete-depth-and-atom-adequacy", "state": "terminal_concept_raw_scaffold_and_handoff_complete", "review_reconciliation_path": "docs/round_20_depth_and_substance_reconciliation_2026_07_27.md", "round_21_adjudication_path": "docs/round_21_depth_contract_and_atom_adequacy_adjudication_2026_07_28.md", "round_22_adjudication_path": "docs/round_22_evidence_pivot_and_concept_atom_adjudication_2026_07_30.md", "chapter_substance_contract_path": "evidence_quality/chapter_substance_contract.json", "four_chapter_atom_addendum_path": "evidence_quality/round20_four_chapter_claim_atom_addendum.json", "concept_linked_atom_addendum_path": "evidence_quality/round22_concept_linked_claim_atom_addendum.json", "manifest_chapter_count_freeze": 84, "chapter_growth_authority": "frozen_until_thin_and_atom_debt_are_zero_or_terminally_justified", "word_trigger": 5000, "word_trigger_is_acceptance_or_evidence_gate": false, "baseline_thin_chapter_count": 23, "baseline_median_word_count": 6982, "current_thin_chapter_count": 11, "priority_chapter_count": 23, "priority_concept_count": 184, "priority_concepts_passing": 184, "priority_chapters": [ "dangerous-capability-domains-and-misuse-uplift", "content-authenticity-watermarking-and-synthetic-media-integrity", "societal-resilience-and-misuse-defense", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity", "durable-semantic-memory-and-knowledge-lattices", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment", "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints", "multi-agent-dynamics-collective-intelligence-and-systemic-risk", "military-ai-autonomous-weapons-and-strategic-stability", "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "human-ai-symbiosis-neurotechnology-and-cognitive-sovereignty", "relational-dimension-compilation-and-polyadic-cognition", "learning-theory-generalization-and-scaling-science", "confidential-and-verifiable-ai-computation", "embodied-agency-real-time-control-and-physical-safety", "inner-alignment-mesa-optimization-and-learned-objective-integrity", "human-ai-organizations-delegation-and-accountability" ], "pre_repair_unified_atom_covered_chapter_count": 80, "pre_repair_uncovered_chapter_count": 4, "new_atom_count": 20, "current_unified_atom_covered_chapter_count": 84, "diagnostic_thin_chapters": [ "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface", "confidential-and-verifiable-ai-computation", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment", "perception-sensor-fusion-and-observation-trust", "human-ai-symbiosis-neurotechnology-and-cognitive-sovereignty", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency", "learning-theory-generalization-and-scaling-science", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance" ], "remaining_concept_completion_queue": [], "required_concept_elements": [ "mechanism", "failure_mode", "non_claim", "source_grounding" ], "completion_authority": "named_concept_contract_plus_current_digest_bound_semantic_disposition", "current_digest_bound_semantic_review_count": 23, "next_priority_batch_size": 0, "next_priority_batch": [], "throughput_unit": "concept_complete_digest_bound_semantic_dispositions", "initial_low_atom_count_diagnostic_chapter_count": 19, "concept_linked_decomposition_chapter_count": 13, "concept_linked_decomposition_atom_count": 104, "low_atom_count_diagnostic_chapter_count": 6, "single_atom_diagnostic_chapter_count": 0, "remaining_manual_decomposition_chapters": [ "human-factors-and-meaningful-control-in-oversight", "privacy-data-rights-and-information-flow-governance", "governed-world-models-and-reality-grounding", "governed-model-training-distributed-optimization-and-scaling", "white-box-evidence-interpretability-and-activation-governance", "governed-operations-incident-command-and-graceful-degradation" ], "atom_adequacy_rule": "one_bounded_claim_addressable_atom_per_material_concept_or_explicit_many_to_one_justification", "atom_count_parity_is_acceptance_target": false, "reader_facing_w3_repeated_12_grams": 0, "reader_facing_w3_maximum_chapter_spread": 0, "raw_qmd_repeated_12_grams": 905, "raw_qmd_maximum_chapter_spread": 65, "raw_scaffold_audit_required": true, "raw_scaffold_exit": "zero_unjustified_widest_spread_blocks", "raw_scaffold_audit_path": "evidence_quality/p6_9_raw_scaffold_ownership_audit.json", "raw_scaffold_audit_state": "terminal_complete", "raw_scaffold_widest_block_count": 21, "raw_scaffold_generated_owned_block_count": 21, "raw_scaffold_reader_visible_block_count": 0, "raw_scaffold_unjustified_block_count": 0, "evidence_handoff_requires": [ "chapter_identity", "concept_identity", "atom_identity", "source_identity", "falsifier", "evidence_lane", "maximum_inference", "unresolved_challenge" ], "evidence_handoff_path": "evidence_quality/p6_9_proof_evidence_handoff.json", "evidence_handoff_state": "terminal_complete", "evidence_handoff_chapter_count": 23, "evidence_handoff_concept_count": 184, "evidence_handoff_missing_identity_count": 0, "p6_9_terminal": true, "manual_semantic_review_required": true, "short_reference_exception_requires_dated_chapter_specific_justification": true, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "predecessor": { "path": "docs/post_v2_3_claim_proof_and_sota_challenge_roadmap.md", "status_path": "roadmap_records/post_v2_3_claim_proof_and_sota_challenge_status.json", "state": "completed", "terminal_record": "release_records/2026-07-16-post-v2-3-claim-proof-sota-roadmap-complete-no-public-release.json" }, "activation_truth": { "latest_public_living_book_release": "v2.3.0", "live_working_chapter_count": 87, "activation_registry_atom_count": 3730, "post_activation_addendum_atom_count": 15, "total_structured_atom_count": 3745, "chapter_core_argument_count": 87, "chapter_core_promotion_count": 0, "activation_registry_non_argument_atom_count": 2, "blocked_after_full_attempt_atom_count": 3698, "transition_file_count": 117, "review_accepted_transition_count": 115, "direct_atom_bound_transition_count": 25, "indirect_identity_mapped_transition_count": 90, "resolved_transition_claim_mapping_count": 115, "unresolved_transition_claim_mapping_count": 0, "accepted_no_change_transition_count": 87, "accepted_refuted_transition_count": 3, "accepted_synthetic_test_backed_transition_count": 14, "accepted_prototype_backed_transition_count": 10, "accepted_empirical_test_backed_transition_count": 1, "competence_qualified_natural_non_authored_empirical_transition_count": 0, "external_reproduction_count": 0, "sota_supported_count": 0, "proof_target_count": 340, "lean_module_count": 133, "theorem_declaration_count": 3153, "derived_or_decomposed_theorem_count": 1978, "direct_or_projection_theorem_count": 447, "unknown_or_mixed_theorem_count": 728, "historical_v2_2_approved_exact_local_reader_formats": [ "html" ], "historical_v2_2_bounded_not_release_approved_reader_formats": [ "epub", "docx" ], "historical_v2_2_failed_reader_formats": [ "pdf" ], "current_published_reader_release_id": "reader-2026-07-18", "current_published_reader_formats": [ "pdf", "epub", "docx" ], "x_article_state": "source_ready_composer_refresh_required", "x_article_draft_id": "2077875347220041728", "publication_authority": "none", "support_state_effect": "none" }, "competence_and_identity_contract": { "state": "installed_historical_rehabilitation_complete", "contract_path": "docs/claim_bearing_experiment_competence_standard.md", "negative_inference_levels": [ "N0", "N1", "N2", "N3", "N4", "N5" ], "all_historical_negative_and_no_change_results_require_n_level": true, "historical_broad_negative_inference_quarantined_pending_audit": false, "exploratory_work_may_change_claim_support": false, "held_out_opening_requires_all_competence_gates": true, "natural_non_authored_corpus_required_for_empirical_claim": true, "broad_refutation_requires_independent_reproduction_and_two_transfer_settings": true, "unresolved_claim_mapping_count": 0, "claim_mapping_validator_required": true, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "claim_identity_graph": { "state": "complete", "graph_path": "evidence_quality/claim_identity_graph.json", "schema_path": "schemas/claim_identity_graph.schema.json", "audit_path": "docs/claim_identity_graph_reconciliation.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_claim_identity_graph.py", "accepted_transition_count": 115, "direct_atom_relation_count": 25, "subclaim_relation_count": 61, "proxy_relation_count": 29, "alias_relation_count": 0, "resolved_transition_count": 115, "unresolved_transition_count": 0, "indirect_parent_support_state_effect": "none", "historical_negative_rehabilitation_effect": "none_pending_P1", "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "negative_result_rehabilitation": { "state": "complete", "ledger_path": "evidence_quality/negative_result_rehabilitation.json", "schema_path": "schemas/negative_result_rehabilitation.schema.json", "audit_path": "docs/negative_result_rehabilitation.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_negative_result_rehabilitation.py", "accepted_negative_or_no_change_transition_count": 90, "n0_count": 1, "n1_count": 15, "n2_count": 74, "n3_count": 0, "n4_count": 0, "n5_count": 0, "broad_negative_inference_count": 0, "chapter_core_negative_inference_count": 0, "historical_raw_outcomes_preserved": true, "surface_audit_path": "evidence_quality/negative_inference_surface_audit.json", "surface_audit_validator_path": "scripts/validate_negative_inference_surface_audit.py", "frozen_snapshot_commit": "295642f21a39e2d735553b3a51ef6ba2f5e76d2c", "frozen_snapshot_sha256": "bb20c1f8932e915b392a76ae776c7487817ee734b0cd3684134e2b9d57e75ba1", "frozen_surface_count": 75, "frozen_chapter_surface_count": 55, "current_surface_count": 100, "live_chapter_surface_count": 80, "forbidden_overbroad_phrase_count": 0, "missing_rehabilitation_boundary_count": 0, "blocked_chapter_boundary_failure_count": 0, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p2_frontier_selection": { "state": "selection_complete_competence_preflight_pending", "record_path": "evidence_quality/p2_frontier_selection.json", "schema_path": "schemas/p2_frontier_selection.schema.json", "receipt_path": "docs/p2_frontier_selection.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p2_frontier_selection.py", "candidate_count": 5, "selected_claim_id": "p2.governed_natural_repository_change_admission_joint_frontier", "canonical_parent_atom": "integrated-reference-architecture.invariant.015", "pending_competence_gate_count": 7, "final_heldout_gate_state": "closed", "final_denominator_opened": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p2_development_corpus_preflight": { "state": "natural_corpus_candidate_qualified_for_development_only", "record_path": "evidence_quality/p2_development_corpus_preflight.json", "schema_path": "schemas/p2_development_corpus_preflight.schema.json", "receipt_path": "docs/p2_development_corpus_preflight.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p2_development_corpus_preflight.py", "source_id": "ext_swe_rebench_v2_2026", "eligible_post_snapshot_task_count": 1117, "eligible_repository_count": 532, "eligible_language_count": 20, "development_task_count": 12, "development_repository_count": 12, "development_language_count": 7, "resolvable_image_manifest_count": 12, "construct_gate_state": "pending_four_replacements_dual_evaluator_and_independent_task_review", "resource_gate_state": "pending_peak_memory_cpu_and_frozen_ceiling_before_replacement_draw", "final_pool_selected": false, "final_denominator_opened": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p2_gold_preflight_diagnosis": { "state": "fixed_denominator_dispositioned_replacement_queue_frozen_qualification_pending", "record_path": "evidence_quality/p2_gold_preflight_diagnosis.json", "schema_path": "schemas/p2_gold_preflight_diagnosis.schema.json", "receipt_path": "docs/p2_gold_preflight_diagnosis.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p2_gold_preflight_diagnosis.py", "policy_path": "evidence_quality/p2_task_qualification_and_replacement_policy.json", "policy_validator_path": "scripts/validate_p2_task_qualification_and_replacement_policy.py", "original_development_task_count": 12, "original_exact_pass_count": 7, "independent_parser_recovered_task_count": 1, "qualified_task_count": 8, "excluded_n0_task_count": 4, "replacement_slot_count": 4, "verified_arm_log_count": 62, "attempt_record_count": 8, "replacement_draw_started": true, "resource_ceiling_state": "frozen_queue_drawn_measurement_gate_pending", "construct_gate_state": "pending_four_replacements_dual_evaluator_and_independent_task_review", "final_pool_selected": false, "final_denominator_opened": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p2_replacement_queue": { "state": "metadata_only_queue_frozen_candidate_content_unopened", "record_path": "experiments/p2_governed_repository_admission/corpus/replacement_queue.json", "schema_path": "schemas/p2_replacement_queue.schema.json", "receipt_path": "docs/p2_replacement_queue.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p2_replacement_queue.py", "slot_count": 4, "candidate_count": 30, "unique_candidate_repository_count": 30, "rust_candidate_count": 9, "go_candidate_count": 20, "java_candidate_count": 1, "candidate_task_content_opened": false, "replacement_qualification_started": false, "final_pool_selected": false, "final_denominator_opened": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p2_replacement_execution": { "state": "latest_capacity_and_docker_entry_failed_pool_materialization_not_run_rank5_setup_retry_pending_rank6_closed", "independent_evaluator_calibration_case_count": 32, "rank_one_task_spec_opened_count": 4, "unique_candidate_task_spec_opened_count": 5, "slot1_terminal_candidate_count": 5, "historical_next_rank_before_amendment": 6, "current_setup_retry_rank": 5, "rank6_authorized": false, "pool_materialization_gate_passed": false, "slot1_qualified": false, "candidate_execution_started_count": 2, "candidate_outcome_custody_incident_count": 1, "other_slot_candidate_outcome_opened_count": 0, "final_pool_selected": false, "final_denominator_opened": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none", "lineage_paths": [ "evidence_quality/p2_independent_test_log_evaluator_calibration.json", "evidence_quality/p2_slot1_rank1_cargo_rescue_diagnosis.json", "experiments/p2_governed_repository_admission/sequential_image_preflight/attempts/2026-07-17-slot1-rank2-r1/result.json", "evidence_quality/p2_slot1_rank3_provenance_preflight.json", "evidence_quality/p2_slot1_rank4_task_opening.json", "evidence_quality/p2_slot1_rank4_cargo_rescue_diagnosis.json", "evidence_quality/p2_slot1_rank5_provenance_preflight.json", "evidence_quality/p2_slot1_rank5_image_preflight_diagnosis.json" ] }, "p2_resource_ceiling": { "state": "measurement_semantics_repaired_v2_frozen_before_candidate_outcomes", "record_path": "evidence_quality/p2_resource_ceiling.json", "schema_path": "schemas/p2_resource_ceiling.schema.json", "receipt_path": "docs/p2_resource_ceiling.md", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p2_resource_ceiling.py", "resource_pilot_path": "experiments/p2_governed_repository_admission/resource_pilot/attempts/2026-07-17-apiflask-r1/result.json", "image_pull_ceiling_seconds": 300, "engine_content_size_ceiling_bytes": 1500000000, "virtual_size_upper_bound_ceiling_bytes": 7000000000, "cleanup_stabilization_timeout_seconds": 60, "dependency_setup_ceiling_seconds": 300, "arm_wall_ceiling_seconds": 600, "peak_memory_ceiling_bytes": 6442450944, "minimum_host_free_bytes": 53687091200, "minimum_qualified_task_count": 12, "ceiling_frozen": true, "all_qualified_tasks_remeasured": false, "resource_gate_passed": false, "replacement_draw_started": true, "final_pool_selected": false, "final_denominator_opened": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p2_sequential_materialization_contract": { "state": "latest_entry_failed_pending_capacity_and_docker_recovery_before_complete_pool_recipe_and_receipt_set", "candidate_count": 30, "complete_pool_recipe_set_required_before_rank_opening": true, "task_content_must_remain_closed_during_materialization": true, "pre_content_exact_image_retry_limit": 3, "pre_content_failure_may_skip_or_burn_rank": false, "post_content_infrastructure_failure_may_advance_rank": false, "post_content_replay_allowed": false, "docker_scoped_reclamation_only": true, "non_docker_user_data_deletion_allowed": false, "minimum_host_free_bytes": 53687091200, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "semantic_proof_cluster_inventory": { "state": "all_6_clusters_terminal", "amendment_rule": "dated_machine_validated_amendment_with_terminal_disposition_required", "clusters": [ { "id": "evidence_claim_and_proof_custody", "state": "adequate", "modules": [ "AsiStackProofs.EvidenceStates", "AsiStackProofs.EvidenceTransitionRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ClaimLedgerRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ProofCarryingClaimsRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ProofEnvelope" ] }, { "id": "safety_assurance_and_oversight", "state": "adequate", "modules": [ "AsiStackProofs.SafetyCriticalLifecycle", "AsiStackProofs.SafetyCaseRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ScalableOversightRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.AdversarialEvaluationRefinement" ] }, { "id": "authority_effect_rollback_and_corrigibility", "state": "adequate", "modules": [ "AsiStackProofs.AuthorityEffectRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.Authority", "AsiStackProofs.Replacement", "AsiStackProofs.Corrigibility", "AsiStackProofs.IntentExecutionRefinement" ] }, { "id": "learning_update_state_and_unlearning", "state": "adequate", "modules": [ "AsiStackProofs.DataEngineLifecycleRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.PolicyOptimizationRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ModelWeightCustody", "AsiStackProofs.ContextTransactionRefinement" ] }, { "id": "self_improvement_and_readiness", "state": "adequate", "modules": [ "AsiStackProofs.SelfImprovementRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.OpenEndedImprovementRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ReadinessRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.CapabilityThresholdRefinement" ] }, { "id": "resource_artifact_and_lifecycle_economics", "state": "adequate", "modules": [ "AsiStackProofs.ResourceEconomicsRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ArtifactRealityRefinement", "AsiStackProofs.ArtifactStewardAgents", "AsiStackProofs.ArtifactCompressionRefinement" ] } ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "p5_effect_complete_reference": { "state": "in_progress_prospective_natural_campaign_frozen_outcomes_closed", "first_slice": { "result_path": "experiments/effect_complete_reference/results/2026-07-27-local.json", "report_path": "docs/p5_effect_complete_reference_report.md", "case_count": 8, "passed_case_count": 8, "boundary": "real_subprocess_sqlite_wal_and_local_filesystem_with_deterministic_state_payloads" }, "stateful_service_slice": { "source_commit": "88d9cc8979460636587fddbf826d62455907c42c", "source_branch": "main", "result_path": "experiments/effect_complete_service/results/2026-07-27-local.json", "report_path": "docs/p5_stateful_service_reference_report.md", "case_count": 7, "passed_case_count": 7, "learning_state_class_count": 9, "mutated_learning_state_class_count": 9, "training_steps": 24, "loss_before": 6.935, "loss_after": 1.18797138562, "weights_only_rollback_rejected": true, "crash_exit_code": 17, "restored_state_class_count": 9, "restored_prediction_exact": true, "localhost_partition_failed_closed": true, "owned_outbox_count_during_partition": 1, "accepted_external_effect_count": 1, "duplicate_retry_count": 1, "revoked_effect_count": 0, "independent_observer_process": true, "weight_tamper_rejected": true, "dependency_tamper_rejected": true, "attestation_scope": "local_source_and_runtime_identity_not_deployment" }, "p5_u1_repository_change_demonstrator": { "state": "terminal_retrospective_natural_defect_replay_and_reader_route", "design_path": "experiments/p5_u1_governed_repository_change/design.json", "result_path": "experiments/p5_u1_governed_repository_change/results/2026-08-13-local.json", "schema_path": "schemas/p5_u1_governed_repository_change_result.schema.json", "runner_path": "scripts/run_p5_u1_governed_repository_change.py", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p5_u1_governed_repository_change.py", "report_path": "docs/p5_effect_complete_reference_report.md", "classification": "retrospective_replay_of_naturally_arising_repository_defect", "route_count": 3, "path_count": 4, "trial_count": 12, "state_checks_passed": 12, "rejecting_record_mutation_count": 9, "governed_authority_blocks": 1, "governed_crash_recoveries": 1, "governed_compensations": 1, "governance_rent_comparator_count": 2, "governance_rent_matched_path_count_per_comparator": 4, "operator_burden_measure": "operator_steps_proxy", "operator_active_time_observed": false, "outcome_known_before_route_replay": true, "fresh_checkout_validated": true, "fresh_checkout_commit": "8bff377f482cd4014945be08957b8cadd82fd68a", "prospective_utility_estimate": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "natural_publication_service_development_trace": { "source_commit": "5575d3cbf5f9dd9edfec8548c4279728b0da3995", "source_branch": "main", "trace_path": "experiments/p5_natural_publication_service_trace/results/2026-07-27-development.json", "report_path": "docs/p5_natural_publication_service_development_trace.md", "classification": "retrospective_natural_happy_path_development_observation", "build_run_id": 30287899588, "deploy_run_id": 30288922224, "artifact_id": 8661958792, "artifact_digest": "sha256:84700830e2f110e1b4406dc1dbc3976b0b2cecc9020455040706d128c3741dc2", "deployment_id": 5626866545, "public_url": "https://corbensorenson.github.io/asi-stack-book/", "source_to_deployment_status_seconds": 873, "source_to_monitor_completion_seconds": 893, "external_service_boundary_count": 3, "no_rebuild_deployment": true, "post_deploy_monitor_separate_process": true, "institutionally_independent": false, "eligible_for_held_out_denominator": false, "claim_bearing": false }, "prospective_natural_stateful_campaign": { "campaign_id": "governed-operations-natural-service-campaign-001", "protocol_path": "experiments/governed_operations_argument_exit/preregistration.json", "report_path": "docs/p5_natural_stateful_service_campaign_preregistration.md", "schema_path": "schemas/governed_operations_campaign_preregistration.schema.json", "state": "implementation_and_instrument_qualified_development_content_still_closed", "frozen_date": "2026-07-28", "service_id": "asi-stack-natural-repository-maintenance-v1", "model_repository": "mlx-community/Qwen3-8B-4bit", "model_snapshot_commit": "545dc4251c05440727734bcd94334791f6ab0192", "arm_count": 5, "task_family_count": 5, "development_task_count": 15, "heldout_task_count": 40, "fault_class_count": 12, "state_class_count": 14, "external_dependency_count": 5, "competence_gate_count": 9, "positive_control_count": 6, "adversarial_control_count": 10, "fair_rescue_step_count": 7, "co_primary_outcome_count": 4, "secondary_outcome_count": 9, "cost_metric_count": 11, "task_content_opened": 0, "protected_outcomes_opened": false, "institutionally_independent": false, "t4_substitution_allowed": false, "public_effects_during_trials": false, "qualification": { "result_path": "experiments/governed_operations_argument_exit/qualification/2026-07-28-local.json", "schema_path": "schemas/governed_operations_campaign_qualification.schema.json", "runner_path": "scripts/run_p5_natural_service_campaign_qualification.py", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p5_natural_service_campaign_qualification.py", "report_path": "docs/p5_natural_stateful_service_campaign_qualification.md", "trial_count": 60, "process_launch_count": 213, "calibration_case_count": 24, "qualification_gate_count": 14, "natural_tasks_run": 0, "development_opening_gate_passed": true, "development_task_content_opened": false, "heldout_opening_gate_passed": false, "actual_twenty_four_hour_elapsed_monitor_evidence": false, "model_quality_evaluated": false, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "admission_gate": { "state": "executable_canonical_task_and_outcome_custody_closed", "candidate_schema_path": "schemas/p5_natural_task_candidate.schema.json", "admission_schema_path": "schemas/p5_natural_task_admission.schema.json", "custody_schema_path": "schemas/p5_natural_task_intake_custody.schema.json", "command_path": "scripts/admit_p5_natural_task.py", "validator_path": "scripts/validate_p5_natural_task_admission.py", "canonical_admitted_task_count": 0, "canonical_natural_task_outcome_count": 0, "fixture_family_count": 5, "fixture_development_assignment_count": 15, "fixture_heldout_assignment_count": 40, "rejecting_control_count": 18, "heldout_content_redacted": true, "requalification_required_before_execution": true, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" } }, "next_action": "admit_consecutive_eligible_natural_development_tasks_only_as_independently_necessary_work_arises_run_the_frozen_five_arm_fault_and_full_cost_procedure_recalibrate_after_any_change_and_complete_development_only_precision_simulation_without_opening_heldout_content", "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "attestation": { "required_branch": "main", "branches_allowed_for_book_work": false, "attested_head": "cef11abd5fca0a421087b3123c1defb31f2b4e6d", "state": "pushed_deployed_clean_ancestral_checkpoint", "working_tree_delta_file_count_at_review": 0, "build_run_id": 30410938617, "deploy_run_id": 30411437258, "tested_artifact_verified": true, "deploy_rebuilt": false, "public_crawl_passed": true, "commit_authority": "owner_authorized_in_thread", "push_authority": "owner_authorized_in_thread", "required_reconciliation": "next_public_release_commit_must_be_clean_and_attested_by_release_receipt" }, "reader_release_receipt": { "state": "published_public_assets_redownload_verified", "release_id": "reader-2026-07-18", "tag": "reader-2026-07-18", "release_commit": "0921a92484cd2a429790f180a4d3ce7bd304446b", "release_url": "https://github.com/corbensorenson/asi-stack-book/releases/tag/reader-2026-07-18", "manifest_path": "editions/reader_manuscript/reader_2026_07_18/manifest.json", "release_record_path": "release_records/2026-07-18-reader-2026-07-18-0921a924.json", "published_formats": [ "pdf", "epub", "docx" ], "public_redownload_sha256_match_count": 3, "canonical_living_release": "v2.3.0", "rights_state": "all_rights_reserved", "accessibility_conformance_claimed": false, "support_state_effect": "none" }, "manim_visual_edition": { "id": "P7.3-governed-manim-visual-edition", "state": "active_generation_2_production_with_private_generation_1_predecessors_preserved", "execution_role": "active_owner_directed_book_packet_p2_scientific_headline_unchanged", "canonical_chapter_count": 87, "normal_visual_abstract_duration_seconds": { "minimum": 150, "maximum": 270 }, "pilot_chapter_ids": [ "asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model", "capability-replacement-and-rollback", "context-transactions-snapshots-mounts-and-taint", "replaceable-cognitive-substrates-beyond-transformer-monoculture", "living-book-methodology" ], "toolchain": { "implementation": "Manim Community Edition", "initial_pin": "0.20.1", "contract_path": "visual_edition/toolchain.json", "requirements_lock_path": "visual_edition/requirements.lock.txt", "qualification_state": "qualified_for_all_non_latex_chapters", "manimgl_allowed": false, "isolated_arm_native_environment_required": true, "broken_global_environment_allowed": false, "exact_dependency_and_render_identity_required": true, "upgrade_requires_five_pilot_compatibility_rerender": true }, "visual_grammar": { "contract_path": "visual_edition/visual_grammar.json", "state": "technical_visual_grammar_v1_ratified_pedagogical_acceptance_reopened", "ratification_requires_all_five_pilots_validated": true }, "pedagogical_and_aesthetic_ratchet": { "id": "P7.3-F9", "state": "active_repository_tracked_v3_treatment_production", "skill_name": "asi-stack-manim-videos", "skill_path": "skills/asi-stack-manim-videos/SKILL.md", "treatment_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_treatment.v1", "treatment_schema_path": "schemas/manim_treatment.schema.json", "beat_plan_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_beat_plan.v4", "beat_plan_schema_path": "schemas/manim_beat_plan.schema.json", "experience_review_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_experience_review.v4", "experience_review_schema_path": "schemas/manim_experience_review.schema.json", "review_context_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_review_context_manifest.v1", "review_context_schema_path": "schemas/manim_review_context_manifest.schema.json", "render_receipt_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_render_receipt.v1", "render_receipt_schema_path": "schemas/manim_render_receipt.schema.json", "sandbox_policy_receipt_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_sandbox_policy_receipt.v1", "sandbox_policy_receipt_schema_path": "schemas/manim_sandbox_policy_receipt.schema.json", "primitive_regression_schema_version": "asi_stack.manim_primitive_regression.v1", "primitive_regression_schema_path": "schemas/manim_primitive_regression.schema.json", "primitive_regression_manifest_path": "visual_edition/primitive_regression_manifest.json", "production_ledger_path": "visual_edition/manim_v2_production_ledger.json", "production_ledger_schema_path": "schemas/manim_v2_production_ledger.schema.json", "production_validator_path": "scripts/validate_manim_v2_production_ledger.py", "narration_toolchain_path": "visual_edition/narration_toolchain.json", "narration_auditor_path": "skills/asi-stack-manim-videos/scripts/audit_video_plan.py", "scene_source_auditor_path": "skills/asi-stack-manim-videos/scripts/audit_scene_source.py", "isolated_render_runner_path": "skills/asi-stack-manim-videos/scripts/render_scene_isolated.py", "final_render_receipt_compiler_path": "skills/asi-stack-manim-videos/scripts/build_final_render_receipt.py", "primitive_regression_auditor_path": "skills/asi-stack-manim-videos/scripts/audit_primitive_regression.py", "target_generation": 2, "normal_visual_abstract_duration_seconds": { "minimum": 150, "maximum": 270 }, "normal_narration_word_count": { "minimum": 280, "maximum": 520 }, "long_form_rationale_required_above_words": 600, "maximum_narration_word_count": 650, "minimum_frame_samples_per_beat": 5, "forced_alignment_required_before_picture_and_sound_lock": true, "source_aware_release_review_required": true, "cold_independent_proxy_required": true, "cold_proxy_is_human_learning_evidence": false, "isolated_render_execution_required": true, "isolated_render_live_policy_controls_pass": true, "isolated_render_real_manim_and_ffmpeg_smoke_pass": true, "isolated_render_negative_control_count": 9, "production_validator_rejecting_control_count": 96, "local_scene_helper_import_contract": "visual_edition.lib.asi_visuals_only", "component_scoped_invalidation_required": true, "generation_2_scene_source_preflight_pass_count": 24, "primitive_regression_frame_count": 2, "primitive_regression_public_factory_count": 9, "legacy_generation_one_explicit_opt_in_required": true, "generation_2_counts": { "planned": 63, "narration_draft": 20, "treated": 0, "script_passed": 0, "beat_planned": 4, "animatic_passed": 0, "picture_and_sound_lock_passed": 0, "release_candidate_passed": 0, "independent_release_candidate_passed": 0, "accepted": 0, "youtube_current": 0, "quarto_current": 0 }, "first_replacement": { "chapter_id": "asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model", "duration_seconds": 156.48, "beat_count": 21, "stage": "beat_planned", "gate_state": "not_started", "historical_review_paths": [ "visual_edition/chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model/generation-2/reviews/animatic-r1.json", "visual_edition/chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model/generation-2/reviews/animatic-r2.json", "visual_edition/chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model/generation-2/reviews/animatic-r3.json", "visual_edition/chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model/generation-2/reviews/picture_and_sound_lock.json" ], "current_review_path": "visual_edition/chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model/generation-2/reviews/animatic.json", "current_candidate_review_state": "source_bound_treatment_and_script_passed_block_timed_animatic_rendered_playback_review_pending", "narration_sha256": "afcffea62fd59b212508ab18b33b8830d9360e7a138879c553581d64990aa23d", "support_state_effect": "none", "publication_effect": "none" }, "required_briefs": [ "audience", "content_contract", "story", "packaging", "art_direction", "audio_direction", "accessibility" ], "required_story_functions": [ "teaching_promise", "concrete_case", "mechanism_relationship_or_tradeoff", "test_or_consequence", "boundary", "payoff" ], "required_authoring_passes": [ "treatment", "script", "beat_plan", "animatic", "picture_and_sound_lock", "release_candidate", "independent_release_candidate" ], "experience_dimensions": [ "teaching_clarity", "composition", "motion_quality", "synchronization", "continuity", "pacing", "voice", "sound_mix", "engagement", "accessibility", "claim_fidelity" ], "minimum_score_each_scored_dimension": 4, "averaging_may_hide_failure": false, "external_human_prepublication_gate_required": false, "beat_density_and_technique_counts_are_diagnostic_only": true, "mechanical_diagnostic_is_aesthetic_verdict": false, "generation_one_first_master_diagnostic": { "chapter_id": "asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model", "duration_seconds": 305.6, "freeze_interval_count_at_least_six_seconds": 6, "freeze_duration_seconds_minimum": 32.533, "freeze_duration_seconds_maximum": 42.9, "integrated_loudness_lufs": -16.4, "loudness_range_lu": 2.6, "true_peak_dbtp": -1.4, "interpretation": "confirms_visual_rhythm_defect_while_audio_meter_result_remains_acceptable_no_learning_or_beauty_claim" }, "remediation_order": [ "write_source_bound_treatments_and_pass_scripts_for_narration_drafts_1_through_24", "qualify_alignment_and_complete_five_pilot_animatics", "continue_in_current_manifest_order" ] }, "hosting": { "canonical_binary_host": "YouTube", "channel_name": "corben sorenson", "channel_id": "UCX7Tu67cGmKfT6O38xxiQFA", "channel_contract_path": "visual_edition/youtube_channel.json", "youtube_ledger_path": "visual_edition/youtube_ledger.json", "authenticated_dashboard_access_verified": true, "canonical_playlist_required": true, "canonical_playlist_id": null, "youtube_video_count_target": 87, "quarto_embed_only_after_published_current": true, "action_time_authority_required": true, "external_publication_authorized_now": false }, "repository_boundary": { "tracked_small_artifacts": [ "scene_code", "storyboard", "narration_script", "reviewed_captions", "descriptive_transcript", "thumbnail", "video_manifest", "render_receipt", "sandbox_policy_receipt", "platform_receipt" ], "rendered_video_binary_tracked_in_git": false, "rendered_video_binary_in_pages_artifact": false, "local_render_location_class": "ignored_build_space" }, "lifecycle_states": [ "planned", "storyboarded", "scripted", "rendered", "validated", "ready_not_published", "published_current", "stale", "superseded" ], "staleness_triggers": [ "core_claim", "mechanism", "worked_trace", "evidence_state", "non_claim", "material_source", "chapter_identity", "handoff", "public_url" ], "current_counts": { "toolchain_contracts": 1, "candidate_visual_grammars": 0, "ratified_visual_grammars": 1, "pilot_packets_present": 5, "pilot_packets_rendered_local": 5, "pilot_packets_validated": 5, "chapter_packets_validated": 84, "current_rendered_videos": 0, "youtube_videos_unlisted_preview": 0, "youtube_videos_published": 0, "current_quarto_preview_embeds": 0, "current_quarto_embeds": 0, "stale_videos": 84 }, "visual_manifest_path": "visual_edition/manifest.json", "youtube_ledger_path": "visual_edition/youtube_ledger.json", "five_pilot_checkpoint": { "generation": 1, "historical": true, "state": "all_five_final_av_masters_validated", "packet_count": 5, "rendered_lifecycle_count": 5, "validated_final_av_count": 5, "rights_cleared_narration_count": 5, "release_visual_review_count": 5, "visual_grammar_state": "ratified", "remaining_release_gates": [ "exact_action_time_youtube_authority" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "first_pilot_checkpoint": { "generation": 1, "historical": true, "chapter_id": "asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model", "packet_path": "visual_edition/chapters/asi-is-a-stack-not-a-model/packet.json", "lifecycle_state": "ready_not_published", "draft_duration_seconds": 284.99707, "draft_dimensions": "854x480", "draft_frame_rate": 15, "visual_review_sample_count": 8, "release_visual_render_present": true, "release_visual_duration_seconds": 284.999023, "release_visual_dimensions": "1920x1080", "release_visual_frame_rate": 30, "release_visual_review_sample_count": 2, "local_timing_audio_publication_rights_cleared": false, "remaining_release_gates": [ "exact_action_time_youtube_authority" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "all_chapter_checkpoint": { "generation": 1, "historical": true, "state": "generation_one_84_packet_archive_with_current_projection_withdrawn", "current_projection_state": "zero_youtube_objects_zero_quarto_embeds", "publication_preflight_path": "visual_edition/youtube_publication_preflight.json", "mutation_scope_path": "visual_edition/youtube_mutation_scope.json", "mutation_scope_sha256": "3f901ca06169b3df555b6e8dbc6a327c6dab9e623b6712407cf0a9366eeb55f0", "mutation_scope_requires_exact_action_time_authorization": true, "platform_receipt_schema_path": "schemas/youtube_platform_receipt.schema.json", "platform_receipt_recorder_path": "scripts/record_youtube_platform_receipt.py", "publication_reconciler_path": "scripts/reconcile_youtube_publication_receipts.py", "supersession_plan_schema_path": "schemas/youtube_supersession_plan.schema.json", "supersession_lifecycle_helper_path": "scripts/visual_publication_lifecycle.py", "supersession_preparer_path": "scripts/prepare_youtube_supersession.py", "supersession_receipt_recorder_path": "scripts/record_youtube_supersession_receipt.py", "supersession_reconciler_path": "scripts/reconcile_youtube_supersession_receipt.py", "supersession_validator_path": "scripts/validate_youtube_supersession_workflow.py", "generation_history_derived_from_immutable_receipts": true, "supersession_negative_mutations_rejected": 12, "current_supersession_plan_count": 0, "real_generation_two_exercise_state": "active_predecessor_publication_not_required", "canonical_chapter_digest_excludes_managed_visual_block": true, "repository_reconciliation_rollback_complete": true, "published_receipt_set_all_or_nothing": true, "publication_input_triples_ready": 84, "studio_browser_batch_count": 6, "data_api_default_minimum_quota_days": 5, "packet_count": 84, "validated_final_av_count": 84, "reviewed_caption_count": 84, "descriptive_transcript_count": 84, "reviewed_thumbnail_count": 84, "scene_midpoint_review_frame_count": 588, "scene_midpoint_review_sheet_count": 21, "content_word_error_rate_minimum": 0.0, "content_word_error_rate_maximum": 0.028658, "maximum_contiguous_expected_token_gap": 4, "duration_seconds_minimum": 227.765, "duration_seconds_maximum": 331.005, "local_final_master_bytes": 1015153522, "youtube_platform_object_count": 0, "current_quarto_embed_count": 0, "remaining_release_gates": [ "exact_action_time_youtube_authority", "youtube_playlist_upload_metadata_caption_thumbnail_processing_publication_receipts", "quarto_embed_and_public_crawl_reconciliation" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none" }, "completion_requires": [ "all_current_manifest_chapters_have_validated_generation_2_derivative_packets", "all_current_manifest_chapters_have_current_rendered_visual_abstracts", "all_current_manifest_chapters_have_v2_beat_plans_with_story_art_audio_and_accessibility_briefs", "all_current_manifest_chapters_have_chapter_specific_signature_visuals_and_persistent_state_change_sequences", "all_current_manifest_chapters_have_five_sample_per_beat_review_sheets", "all_current_manifest_chapters_pass_qualified_alignment_before_picture_and_sound_lock", "all_release_candidates_pass_cold_comprehension_and_transfer_review", "minimum_four_of_five_on_every_experience_dimension_without_average_laundering", "reviewed_captions_and_descriptive_transcripts", "zero_stale_video_claim_surfaces", "youtube_playlist_and_exact_platform_receipts_or_84_ready_not_published_authority_disposition", "validated_quarto_embeds_for_every_published_current_video", "no_rendered_video_binaries_in_git_or_pages", "full_render_link_responsive_keyboard_accessibility_tree_and_public_crawl_pass", "zero_support_state_movement" ], "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none_until_validated_youtube_publication_receipts" }, "priorities": [ { "id": "P0", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "reconcile public truth, claim identity, and main-only commit attestation" }, { "id": "P1", "state": "completed", "purpose": "rehabilitate historical negative results and prevent false-negative inference" }, { "id": "P2", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "produce one competence-qualified natural non-authored empirical result" }, { "id": "P3", "state": "pending", "purpose": "establish independent reproduction, transfer, and honest SOTA challenges" }, { "id": "P4", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "preserve terminal local proof custody while rationalizing theorem families and proving bounded cross-owner composition" }, { "id": "P5", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "build and test an effect-complete governed reference system" }, { "id": "P6", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "renew sources, comparators, evaluators, instruments, and false-negative controls" }, { "id": "P7", "state": "completed", "purpose": "preserve all 87 research identities in the completed metadata-first 56-chapter architecture, seven-profile, two-dossier, one-registry, and deployed independent 26-unit HTML narrative without overclaim" }, { "id": "P8", "state": "pending", "purpose": "close every residual with an exact disposition and successor continuity" } ], "milestones": [ { "id": "M0", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "operate truth, identity, and attestation control" }, { "id": "M1", "state": "completed", "purpose": "classify historical negative inference under N0 through N5" }, { "id": "M2", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "complete a competent natural empirical campaign without forced promotion" }, { "id": "M3", "state": "pending", "purpose": "reproduce and transfer every broadened claim" }, { "id": "M4", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "retain semantically meaningful local evidence and close bounded cross-owner composition" }, { "id": "M5", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "validate effect-complete multi-process governed behavior" }, { "id": "M6", "state": "in_progress", "purpose": "keep evidence and instrument renewal current" }, { "id": "M7", "state": "completed", "purpose": "complete and deploy the independent human HTML narrative while preserving separately owned derivative publication custody" }, { "id": "M8", "state": "pending", "purpose": "activate the next exact authority" } ], "self_contained_execution": { "hosted_chat_dependency": false, "external_human_prepublication_required": false, "routine_local_work_additional_user_authorization_required": false, "external_mutation_action_time_authority_required": true }, "closure_requires_active_successor": true, "support_state_effect": "none", "release_effect": "none", "non_claims": [ "Roadmap revision does not promote, refute, rehabilitate, or reclassify any claim by itself.", "An accepted transition is not necessarily an exact registry-atom transition until its identity edge is validated.", "A historical negative outcome remains observable even when broader negative inference is quarantined.", "A competence contract cannot guarantee a perfect experiment; it forces inadequate tests to fail closed.", "A Manim scene, render, upload, playlist entry, or polished animation is an explanatory derivative and does not establish proof, empirical support, capability, safety, deployment readiness, SOTA, AGI, or ASI.", "This revision does not authorize commit, push, tag, deploy, archive deposit, license change, publication, or release." ], "no_deferral_manuscript_admission": { "state": "terminal_argument_level_admission", "date": "2026-07-24", "policy": "Every worthwhile manuscript idea is integrated now, admitted as a distinct owner now, or explicitly rejected with a reason; only evidence maturity may remain open.", "previous_manifest_chapter_count": 66, "current_manifest_chapter_count": 80, "admitted_chapter_ids": [ "human-ai-communication-persuasion-and-epistemic-security", "governed-objective-formation-value-learning-and-goal-integrity", "institutions-international-coordination-and-public-legitimacy", "adversarial-machine-learning-and-model-attack-surface", "autonomous-replication-proliferation-and-containment", "durable-semantic-memory-and-knowledge-lattices", "ai-deployment-transition-distribution-and-human-agency", "learning-theory-generalization-and-scaling-science", "physical-compute-infrastructure-energy-and-environmental-constraints", "scientific-discovery-and-experimental-governance", "dangerous-capability-domains-and-misuse-uplift", "societal-resilience-and-misuse-defense", "open-weight-release-and-post-release-control", "content-authenticity-watermarking-and-synthetic-media-integrity" ], "remaining_live_candidate_queue_count": 0, "structural_freeze_for_manuscript_ideas": false, "all_chapter_core_support_states": "argument", "chapter_core_support_state_effect": "none", "current_semantically_reviewed_chapter_count": 68, "current_structured_atom_count": 4064 } }