84  Logical Conclusion Status

85 Logical Conclusion Status

This page is the machine-readable release ledger for the roadmap’s 90 acceptance criteria. It does not redefine completion around what is already easy to prove: human canon signoff, public package-index upload, non-maintainer adoption, and non-Codex/reviewer hardness evidence remain explicitly pending until recorded evidence exists.

Raw data: logical_conclusion_status.json

85.1 Summary

Status	Count
Proven	84
Partial	1
Pending human	2
Pending package index	1
Pending external	2
Total criteria	90

External claims fabricated: false

85.2 Open Gates

Gate	Criteria	Status	Blocker
Human canon audit	69, 70	pending human	Named maintainer review, date, decision, and correction outcome must be recorded before human audit or canonical promotion can be claimed.
Public package index	72, 88	pending package index	TestPyPI/PyPI upload must be performed by a named maintainer before public package-index smoke checks can run.
External adoption	74	pending external	At least three non-maintainer reports must be accepted and published with friction/failure fields intact.
Non-Codex hardness surface	79	pending external	At least one additional non-Codex or reviewer-supplied hardness surface must be validated and accepted before cross-surface Bench v4 hardness claims are complete.

85.3 Criteria Ledger

#	Status	Criterion
1	proven	Public site teaches the theory clearly.
2	proven	Main book is readable and coherent.
3	proven	Pocket guide is useful as a daily reference.
4	proven	Stacked-spells system is integrated and validated.
5	proven	Full lexicon is structured, navigable, and semantically reviewed.
6	proven	Six initial spells are reusable templates.
7	proven	Six initial stacks are reusable workflows.
8	proven	Spells and stacks have schemas.
9	proven	Validation, tests, render, and link audit run in CI.
10	proven	Quarto publication is automated.
11	proven	Executable fixtures demonstrate Proof by Difference for field spells.
12	proven	Recorded runs show weak-vs-repaired deltas, scores, variance, and non-wins.
13	proven	Project can accept contributions without losing structure.
14	proven	Project has versioned releases.
15	proven	User can move from vague request to structured spell to verified result.
16	proven	Team can move from one-off prompt to reusable stack to versioned practice.
17	proven	Homepage demonstrates practical value before jargon.
18	proven	Every field spell has copyable and raw template forms.
19	proven	Fifty major canon entries are authored and reviewed.
20	proven	Three hundred pocket canon entries are authored and reviewed.
21	proven	All 1,645 lexicon entries have authored fields and sense guidance where needed.
22	proven	Master-lexicon house pages are complete and navigable.
23	proven	Tool-native exports are generated and link to seals.
24	proven	Release-gate stack is instantiated by the repository release process.
25	proven	Seal stability is tested and seal changes are documented.
26	proven	Jailbreaks and prompt injection are covered defensively.
27	proven	Warded-spell trust-boundary schema extension exists.
28	proven	Jailbreak-resilience spell and AI red-team stack exist.
29	proven	Jailbreak-resilience bench has harmless fixtures, scoring, transcripts, and utility scoring.
30	proven	No operational external jailbreak corpus is vendored by default.
31	proven	Lexicon distinguishes generated draft text from reviewed semantic canon.
32	proven	Template-shaped lexicon prose cannot pass as reviewed or canonical.
33	proven	Major and pocket runes have reviewed force, shadow, examples, and prompt-use guidance.
34	proven	Benchmark layer supports declared surfaces and manual imports.
35	proven	Benchmark results include deterministic checks, metadata, variance, and limitations.
36	proven	Adversarial harness covers mediation, retrieval taint, scope creep, drift, canary redaction, and overrefusal.
37	proven	Exported assets ship with manifest, checksums, schema versions, source IDs, and seals.
38	proven	CLI/package can validate and seal user-owned spells outside source data.
39	proven	Generator is split into maintainable modules with deterministic tests.
40	proven	Diagram placeholders are replaced by generated visual instruments.
41	proven	Task chooser maps real work to spell, stack, template, and verification path.
42	proven	Adoption, canon correction, and reviewer-run import paths are published without fabricating evidence.
43	proven	Field-spell evaluation includes clean and trap tiers.
44	proven	Execution-graded cases preserve command, streams, exit code, timeout, and grader version.
45	proven	Benchmark pages separate reviewability, outcome, execution, variance, and limitations.
46	proven	At least two model/tool surfaces are recorded or imported for field-spell bench.
47	proven	Every jailbreak-resilience case has baseline and warded variants.
48	proven	Adversarial matrix includes baseline failure and warded resistance/utility/audit reporting.
49	proven	Surface comparison pages show deltas without hiding ties, losses, or failures.
50	proven	Semantic canon has a validated promotion ladder.
51	proven	Per-house semantic progress board exists and two houses are reviewed.
52	proven	Reviewed lexicon count is at least 450.
53	proven	Claude Code exports are generated, validated, checksummed, bundled, and installable.
54	proven	Spell and stack diagrams are data-driven and non-placeholder.
55	proven	Release bundles are produced and attached to GitHub Releases.
56	proven	Calibration artifacts are separated from model-run evidence.
57	proven	Every evidence row carries evidence class and provenance.
58	proven	Calibration rows cannot count as independent model/tool surfaces.
59	proven	Field-spell bench includes a real second model/tool surface beyond original Codex.
60	proven	Surface adapters share normalized metadata contract.
61	proven	Model artifacts can be extracted, sandboxed, and execution-graded safely.
62	proven	Trap-tier field-spell cases include real model outputs and preserved transcripts.
63	proven	At least two field-spell cases grade model-produced artifacts by execution.
64	proven	Jailbreak-resilience A/B comparisons include real model runs.
65	proven	At least one adversarial baseline failure is model-produced.
66	proven	Evidence dashboard links from summaries to prompts, transcripts, artifacts, fixtures, scores, and limitations.
67	proven	Live-site smoke checks verify high-value pages and downloads after deployment.
68	proven	Release assets are downloadable and checksum-verifiable after publication.
69	pending human	First two reviewed lexicon houses have human audit records and correction outcomes.
70	pending human	Canonical rune promotion is backed by usage evidence and reviewer signoff.
71	proven	Usage graph links runes to spells, stacks, benchmarks, adoption reports, and accepted evidence.
72	pending package index	CLI is installable from a public package index and passes package-install smoke tests.
73	proven	Public package versioning is tied to evidence milestones.
74	pending external	At least three non-maintainer adoption or reviewer reports are accepted and published.
75	proven	Project preserves ties, losses, overrefusals, failures, and null results.
76	proven	Evaluation pages report deltas per surface, tier, variant, and repetition cell.
77	proven	Structural rubric is renamed to reviewability score.
78	proven	Bench v4 includes five named hardness rungs.
79	pending external	At least two hardness rungs include executable fixtures, artifacts, and cross-surface results.
80	proven	Ward-science pages include real baseline/warded A/B on both primary surfaces for original attack shapes.
81	proven	At least one ward-limb ablation is published with effect/non-effect attribution.
82	proven	Additional defanged attack shapes cover six named morphologies.
83	proven	Resistance-versus-utility reporting prevents blanket refusal from scoring as complete success.
84	proven	Canon-review queue is generated from usage evidence and bounded for human review.
85	proven	Canonical entries require reviewed status, usage evidence, no blocker, and named signoff.
86	proven	One-step local installs exist for Claude Code and Cursor and are tested under repo-local tmp.
87	proven	Adoption-report generation produces schema-valid records without counting dogfood as external adoption.
88	partial	Package-index release materials are ready and package-index smoke checks are added once upload exists.
89	proven	Scratch output policy keeps project commands, docs, tests, and examples under repo-local tmp.
90	proven	Methods write-up is generated from recorded evidence and foregrounds null/tie/task-dependent results.